PDA

View Full Version : Player ratings today



lucky
24-10-2009, 04:30 PM
Stack--7 some very good stops

Wotherspoon --5 struggled defending did well going forward
Bamba--8 excellent
Hogg--6 did fine
Murray 7 played well

McBride 8-- was excellent again with his work rate and covering for others
Miller 7 work hard

Deeks--6 not his best day
Zemmama--6 full of tricks but has to pass earlier

Benji 6 ran his socks of great control but pass others as well his pal
Stokes 7 quiet first half fantastic goal.

Stevenson 5 did well when came on
Nish--4 did OK
Galbraith--4 never got much of a chance

Hughes-9 set the team out to win and changed it when Wotherspoon was struggling

Hibs support 9 excellent

I did not attend the game but watched it online.

blackpoolhibs
24-10-2009, 04:32 PM
Everyone gets a 10 from me, apart from Bamba, he gets an 11.:thumbsup:

Billychaotic182
24-10-2009, 04:41 PM
Stack - 8 What a game. Is stop against boyd kept us in it

Wotherspoon - 5 not a good game. Glad Yogi took the boy off but he will learn from this
Bamba - 9 Great game and never got booked
Hogg - 6 was ok. Scary moments at times
Murray - 7 not his best game for passing but he did was was asked to his high standerd

McBride 9 - My MOM coverd well when players like Murray went forward and ever pass was to the players
Miller - 7 good game. nice passes

Deeks - 6 always looks like he is in the huff with everyone
Zemmama - 7 nice little spells but not his best game

Benji - 7 Linked up well and was awesome 1st half.
Stokes - 8 was a goal and that run OFFT

Stevenson - 6 good to see the wee man back
Nish - 4 missed a sitter
Galbraith - 5 wish this boy got a start

Ell_Chrisso
24-10-2009, 04:42 PM
Stack - 9! Deserves all the credit under the sun today. Were quick to criticise our keepers, but what a performance today. 3 TOP drawer saves to keep us in it

Wotherspoon - 5 Tryed hard, but gets caught out, with high balls. Lost concentration in the goal, ( needs to go into midfield, or be replaced by a RB )
Bamba - 8 Handled the game very well again. Has been outstanding since we got him last year. Wont have him long if continues form
Hogg - 7 Done his job today. Few times got caught out, but filled in well at RB when Spoon got taken off.
Murray - 8 Outstanding i think. Not a ten out of ten, due to done nothing special, but just made everything simple, and stuck to his job well.

McBride - 8 Such workmanlike performance again. Not many players will get into our mid while he is with us. Great pro.
Miller - 9 Yet again superb today. Controlled the midfield when had the ball at his feet. great passes and energy. Another who wont lose his place fast

Deeks - 6 Not at it today. Probably played too wide, to be a major factor.
Zemmama - 6 Same as Riordan. Never got involved enough, to contribute any chance making. Needs to pass the ball quicker at times.

Benji - 5 Agree, that he ran his socks off. But too lazy with the ball at his feet, and with first touch. Can doo soo much better, Would rather Nish Started.
Stokes - 8 Played well, when got the service. Had two or three good chances, and should have smashed a chance late on instead of taking on def. Took goal magnificently!

Stevenson - 6 Slotted in well once come on. Got to the game level very quickly
Nish - 6 Did ok, got into good position, and wasted game winning chance
Galbraith - 5 Never had enough time to much.

Hibs support sounded excellent. Great support through there.

I did not attend the game but watched it online also!

8/10 overall.

cjward2
24-10-2009, 04:44 PM
Miller had a fantastic game. 9/10 and a class act in midfield from the Hibs:thumbsup:

Wotherspiniesta
24-10-2009, 04:45 PM
Stack- 7 Kept us in the game with 3 great saves. One dodgy punch from a corner but did well.

Wotherspoon- 5 Not a right back, but got forward well. Exposed at goal, subbed.

Hogg- 5 He doesn't have the ability to play in a passing team IMO. Bullied off the ball a few times aswell.

Bamba- 7 Solid.

Murray- 8 Brilliant. Kept Naismith quiet and attacked well.

Mcbride- 8 Brilliant team player. Kept it simple and helped out at the back.

Miller- 7 What a signing. Still think there's more to come from him aswell.

Zemmama- 6 Not his best today, but showed in glimpses what he's capable of.

Benji- 7 Great hold up play, close control and a good effort in the first half. Unlucky to be subbed.

Stokes- 8 Grew into the game. Great turn of pace. Wonderful goal and great bit of skill near the end nearly set up winner.

Riordan- 6 Quiet, will probably be quite frustrated at his personal performance but still a threat. Nearly bent one in in first minute. Subbed.

Nish- 2 should have scored.
Galbraith- 4 good option from the bench.
Stevenson- 4 Good tackle near the end.

Yogi- 9 Got the boys playing some great football right now. Playing without fear and his attacking tactics are very refreshing.

Nameless
24-10-2009, 04:56 PM
Everyone gets a 10 from me, apart from Bamba, he gets an 11.:thumbsup:

Waht he said :agree:

euro Hibby
24-10-2009, 07:46 PM
Stack--8 one bad flap the rest perfect.

Wotherspoon --5 struggled in defence, but is learning the role. one good shot.
Bamba--8 excellent especially in the 2nd half
Hogg--6 2nd half a bad pass let Boyd or someone in on goal Ok at right back.
Murray 7 played well

McBride 8-- was excellent again with his work rate and covering for others
Miller 7 solid

Deeks--6 is working more and still always dangerousKept Whits from going forward.
Zemmama--7. good player end of......

Benji 7 for me has become a team player and will get better.
Stokes 7 quiet until his great goal

Stevenson 6 settles quicky and can tackle.
Nish--4 did OK but missed a sitter. probably needs game time
Galbraith--5 ran about but never got into the game

Hughes-9 set the team out to win and changed it when Wotherspoon was struggling


I did not attend the game but watched it online. ( me too )

RoYO!
24-10-2009, 07:51 PM
Stack--8 one bad flap the rest perfect.

Wotherspoon --5 struggled in defence, but is learning the role. one good shot.
Bamba--8 excellent especially in the 2nd half
Hogg--6 2nd half a bad pass let Boyd or someone in on goal Ok at right back.
Murray 7 played well

McBride 8-- was excellent again with his work rate and covering for others
Miller 7 solid

Deeks--6 is working more and still always dangerous Kept Whits from going forward.
Zemmama--7. good player end of......

Benji 7 for me has become a team player and will get better.
Stokes 7 quiet until his great goal

Stevenson 6 settles quicky and can tackle.
Nish--4 did OK but missed a sitter. probably needs game time
Galbraith--5 ran about but never got into the game

Hughes-9 set the team out to win and changed it when Wotherspoon was struggling


I did not attend the game but watched it online. ( me too )

good point, dont recall any of his trademark solo/ surging runs today....


bet walter smith is suffering from surging runs tonight! :wink:

FRes Hibbie
24-10-2009, 08:00 PM
I haven't been part of the 'let's all slag off Stack' brigade and today was my first game this season but I thought he was very dodgy. Thought Murray and Bamba were good. Hogg lost Boyd for their goal and I didn't even notice Wotherspoon. The rest of the team were good.

I wish Hughes didn't take Deek off - he'd have scored any one of the three chances that Nish and Stokes had towards the end.

Sir David Gray
24-10-2009, 09:40 PM
I haven't been part of the 'let's all slag off Stack' brigade and today was my first game this season but I thought he was very dodgy. Thought Murray and Bamba were good. Hogg lost Boyd for their goal and I didn't even notice Wotherspoon. The rest of the team were good.

I wish Hughes didn't take Deek off - he'd have scored any one of the three chances that Nish and Stokes had towards the end.

He made a brilliant stop from Boyd just before half time that probably kept us in the game. I thought that was a certain goal.

Overall, I thought he made some very good saves today.

Expecting Rain
24-10-2009, 09:42 PM
Everyone gets a 10 from me, apart from Bamba, he gets an 11.:thumbsup:


Too much bevy BH!:greengrin