PDA

View Full Version : HIbs best 11 if...we had had them at their peak


heidtheba
09-09-2009, 06:04 PM
Thought I'd have a punt at starting this one. Apologies if it has already been done but its a quiet week and I'm waiting for my take out to arrive!

Criteria - select players who have played for Hibs but mention when they were at their best in their career.

IE Best (during Man U days)
Wilkins (during pre-Gers days)

GK Goram (Rangers)
RB - cant think
LB - Murphy (Hibs)
CD -
CD -

RW - Best (showing ignorance here - rw?) (Man U)
LW - Riordan (Hibs 1st time round)

CM - Wilkins (pre-Gers)
CM - Sauzee (Marseilles)

ST - Riordan
ST - Archibald (Barcelona)
Dashing Bob S
10-09-2009, 04:18 PM
Thought I'd have a punt at starting this one. Apologies if it has already been done but its a quiet week and I'm waiting for my take out to arrive!

Criteria - select players who have played for Hibs but mention when they were at their best in their career.

IE Best (during Man U days)
Wilkins (during pre-Gers days)

GK Goram (Rangers)
RB - cant think
LB - Murphy (Hibs)
CD -
CD -

RW - Best (showing ignorance here - rw?) (Man U)
LW - Riordan (Hibs 1st time round)

CM - Wilkins (pre-Gers)
CM - Sauzee (Marseilles)

ST - Riordan
ST - Archibald (Barcelona)


Goram (Oldham/Hibs/Rangers)

Brownlie (Hibs pre leg break?)
Stanton (Hibs)
Sauzee (Marsailles/Hibs?)
Murphy (Hibs)

Best (Man U)
Wilkins (AC Milan)
Bremner (Hibs/Villa)
Collins (Hibs/Monaco?)

Smith (Hibs)
Baker (Hibs first time?)
Reilly (Hibs)
ancient hibee
10-09-2009, 04:26 PM
Goram

Brownlie Sauzee Stanton

Turnbull

Smith Johnston Hamilton Ormond

Reilly Baker.
Jonnyboy
10-09-2009, 05:56 PM
Goram

Brownlie Sauzee Stanton

Turnbull

Smith Johnston Hamilton Ormond

Reilly Baker.

Now THAT is a football team :thumbsup:
magnificent_seven
11-09-2009, 08:27 AM
Andersson

Murphy
Jones
Murray
Whittaker

Bamba
Beuzelin
Thomson
Brown

O'Connor
Riordan

This team would win the SPL no bother.
Tomsk
11-09-2009, 12:29 PM
Goram (Oldham/Hibs/Rangers)

Brownlie (Hibs pre leg break?)
Stanton (Hibs)
Sauzee (Marsailles/Hibs?)
Murphy (Hibs)

Best (Man U)
Wilkins (AC Milan)
Bremner (Hibs/Villa)
Collins (Hibs/Monaco?)

Smith (Hibs)
Baker (Hibs first time?)
Reilly (Hibs)


I am sure the OP asked for a best 11, Bob. :wink:
southfieldshibby
11-09-2009, 12:44 PM
Goram

Brownlie Sauzee Stanton

Turnbull

Smith Johnston Hamilton Ormond

Reilly Baker.

Surely not Brian????:devil:
J-C
11-09-2009, 12:53 PM
Simpson

Brownlie
Sauzee
Stanton

Turnbull
Smith
Johnston
O'Rourke

Riley
Baker
Best
1two
11-09-2009, 01:11 PM
Andersson

Murphy
Jones
Murray
Whittaker

Bamba
Beuzelin
Thomson
Brown

O'Connor
Riordan

This team would win the SPL no bother.

I doubt it!

Take out Bamba and Andersson and i'm pretty sure that team played together at some stage..??

Although you could argue that they might win the SPL 2009/10 as the OF are very poor this season IMO......??
Jim44
11-09-2009, 01:14 PM
Surely wee Russel Latapy must be in there somewhere. :dunno:
yekimevol
11-09-2009, 02:43 PM
gk anderson
rb whitty
cb sauzze
cb jones
lb murphy
rm sproule
cm brown
cm latapy
lm thomson
cf deco
cf o'conner
:top marks
hibsdaft
11-09-2009, 02:55 PM
Sauzee
Sauzee
Sauzee
Sauzee
Sauzee
Sauzee
Sauzee
Sauzee
Sauzee
Sauzee
Sauzee
Speedy
11-09-2009, 02:57 PM
Andersson

Murphy
Jones
Murray
Whittaker

Bamba
Beuzelin
Thomson
Brown

O'Connor
Riordan

This team would win the SPL no bother.

I wouldn't bet on it