One In, One Out; YOU decide

[Comiston Hibee]

Let's be sensible and not quote the likes of Ronaldo or Ribery In, but given the chance to get a Riordan/Stokes quality type player in, who is your choice, and 1 to say goodbye to is also up to you

In: I don't know

Out: Joe Keenan - a midfielder and I would like another midfielder in, someone in the creative mould of Boozy, but not him


Thoughts?

[Dibben]

In - Scott Arfield

Out - Joe Keenan

BH.

[GB6]

In - Scott Arfield

Out - Joe Keenan

BH.

:top marks

what BH said :agree:

[Randerson_4]

In: Kevin McDonald (Burnley) - not getting his game, exactly the type of midfielder we need, bit and strong, good on the ball, scores goals

Out: Anyone of Keenan, DVZ, JJ

[Comiston Hibee]

In: Kevin McDonald (Burnley) - not getting his game, exactly the type of midfielder we need, bit and strong, good on the ball, scores goals

Out: Anyone of Keenan, DVZ, JJ

did McDonald not play at Chelsea today?

[LamontHFC©]

In: Kevin McDonald (Burnley) - not getting his game, exactly the type of midfielder we need, bit and strong, good on the ball, scores goals

Out: Anyone of Keenan, DVZ, JJ

Nae danger he would come to us.

[LamontHFC©]

did McDonald not play at Chelsea today?

He came on as a sub.

[Randerson_4]

did McDonald not play at Chelsea today?

Came on towards the end, didnt notice that! Noticed the other day, my dad (a dundee fan) mentioned too that he hadnt been playing that often

[Dibben]

did McDonald not play at Chelsea today?

McDonald came on as a sub - presume it's the same one!!

No chance!

BH.

[HibeeUnderwood]

Darren Barr In!

David Van Zanten Out!

Definately not rocket science! :agree:

[Franck is God]

I would be willing to let go any of the following players if a move was available for them. Rankin, Thicot or maybe even Stevenson. I'd like to see more of Lewis under Hughes but he has not moved on at all since JC brought him into the team.

From what I've seen under Hughes so far I think we need a real box to box player in the mould of a Pat McGinlay. McBride holds the ball well and Cregg is a real scrapper but we need a really strong running player that will break from midfield and go for a charge occasionally and I don't mean a jinking run just a head down and run at goal.

A couple of players I saw last year fit that description. Gary McDonald at Aberdeen or Andy Dorman at St Mirren would be on my list.

Also not sure of his availabilty but I'd think about enquiring about Barry Robson at Celtic.

[CB_NO3]

Russell Anderson in

And either Keenan, DVZ, Thicot, Stevenson out

[IWasThere2016]

We need a player who can play CH or RB .. I think Yogi might know of one.

We can only dream about Kevin McDonald as Burnley have too small a squad to allow him to go on loan. He would be perfect for us however :agree:

Keenan will go.

[Petrie's Tache]

[QUOTE=Franck is God;2152581]I would be willing to let go any of the following players if a move was available for them. Rankin, Thicot or maybe even Stevenson. I'd like to see more of Lewis under Hughes but he has not moved on at all since JC brought him into the team.

From what I've seen under Hughes so far I think we need a real box to box player in the mould of a Pat McGinlay. McBride holds the ball well and Cregg is a real scrapper but we need a really strong running player that will break from midfield and go for a charge occasionally and I don't mean a jinking run just a head down and run at goal.

A couple of players I saw last year fit that description. Gary McDonald at Aberdeen or Andy Dorman at St Mirren would be on my list.

Also not sure of his availabilty but I'd think about enquiring about Barry Robson at Celtic.[/QUOTE/]

Somone eluded to this already:agree:

[Petrie's Tache]

We need a player who can play CH or RB .. I think Yogi might know of one.

We can only dream about Kevin McDonald as Burnley have too small a squad to allow him to go on loan. He would be perfect for us however :agree:

Keenan will go.


Barr or A N Other?

[Judas Iscariot]

Keenan is basically oot anyway..

I'd get shot of any of the following..

DVG, JJ, Rankin, Stevenson, McCormack and Hogg..

As long as we were bringing in players of the quality like..

Arfield, Barr, Boozy, Anderson, Robson etc etc

[weststandhibby]

Out - JJ - not kicked a ball for us.

In - Arfield

[keep the faith]

Out - DVZ
In - Barr

Then

Out - Keenan
In - Arfield

Then

Out - Thicot
In - Boozy


Quick as you like please Yogi! :thumbsup:

[erin go bragh]

Nae danger he would come to us.
would you have said the same thing about stokes 2 weeks ago?:wink:

[Speedy]

In: Kevin McDonald (Burnley) - not getting his game, exactly the type of midfielder we need, bit and strong, good on the ball, scores goals

Out: Anyone of Keenan, DVZ, JJ

He's on silly money, he was on over 10k per week last season.

Sauce - His brother's mate. I had only met the guy once though so it's probably not the best sauce :greengrin

[Dibben]

Out - DVZ
In - Barr

Then

Out - Keenan
In - Arfield

Then

Out - Thicot
In - Boozy


Quick as you like please Yogi! :thumbsup:

:agree:

BH.

[Expecting Rain]

Keenan is basically oot anyway..

I'd get shot of any of the following..

DVG, JJ, Rankin, Stevenson, McCormack and Hogg..

As long as we were bringing in players of the quality like..

Arfield, Barr, Boozy, Anderson, Robson etc etc

Pretty similar thoughts to myself, i`d keep Lewis though and give McCormack more time.

[HibeeUnderwood]

Keenan is basically oot anyway..

I'd get shot of any of the following..

DVG, JJ, Rankin, Stevenson, McCormack and Hogg..

As long as we were bringing in players of the quality like..

Arfield, Barr, Boozy, Anderson, Robson etc etc

I'd only agree with getting rid of JJ and DVZ in that lot seeing as we have no real use for them anymore, still don't think Van Zanten will go unless we sign another player who can play right back! The other 4, in the case of Rankin and Hogg, they are quite useful! And in the case of Stevenson and McCormack, they will be quite useful soon! :agree:

I also think that we don't even need Arfield although if we did bring him in I would not complain. Darren Barr would be my priority.Boozy would be good and Anderson would be quite useful to have. I personally think Robson is ***** and past it! :agree:

['Mon the Hibs]

Came on towards the end, didnt notice that! Noticed the other day, my dad (a dundee fan) mentioned too that he hadnt been playing that often

Your dad not getting a game? What position does he play? :wink::greengrin