Longbangers Podcast

[matty_f]

Feeling detached from the club
Too corporate?
What needs to be reviewed?
Do we need an academy?

All this and more in our phone in!
https://www.youtube.com/live/yCHwkq7...ir6PjFNi5GbKg5

[Donegal Hibby]

Enjoyed that ! . Good hearing different opinions . 👍
I could never really understand why fans have it in for certain players and what's to be gained by giving them stick during or after a game , Mckirdy coming on at Aberdeen was a classic example . Suppose some folk are always going to have players to blame for everything like your Campbells , Mckirdy's , Rocky's or Elie Youan's unfortunately.

Just about the youth academy which is a good thing imo , didn't we not get Scott Brown after he was released by Sevco , seem to remember getting told it was because he was to small?.

[Itsnoteasy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Enjoyed that ! . Good hearing different opinions . 👍
I could never really understand why fans have it in for certain players and what's to be gained by giving them stick during or after a game , Mckirdy coming on at Aberdeen was a classic example . Suppose some folk are always going to have players to blame for everything like your Campbells , Mckirdy's , Rocky's or Elie Youan's unfortunately.

Just about the youth academy which is a good thing imo , didn't we not get Scott Brown after he was released by Sevco , seem to remember getting told it was because he was to small?.

Mckirdy was £h1t3 & put a few negative comments about Hibs on his twitter account.

[Bridge hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Mckirdy was £h1t3 & put a few negative comments about Hibs on his twitter account.

I dont think I remember that, what did he say ?

[Donegal Hibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Mckirdy was £h1t3 & put a few negative comments about Hibs on his twitter account.

Was that something about a bench , Chelsea , golf ...... ? .

[Bridge hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Was that something about a bench , Chelsea , golf ...... ? .

So he hates sitting on the bench, supports Chelsea and is **** at golf ?

The only thing wrong with that is admitting you support chelsea and play golf 🤣

[JohnM1875]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Was that something about a bench , Chelsea , golf ...... ? .

That was just a joke to be fair to him. Not a particularly funny one if you're a Hibs fan right enough.

Did he not like a Swindon Town fans post about coming 'back home' last season as well?

[Donegal Hibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

So he hates sitting on the bench, supports Chelsea and is **** at golf ?

The only thing wrong with that is admitting you support chelsea and play golf 🤣

Yeah I'd be keeping that quiet right enough 😂

[Donegal Hibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

That was just a joke to be fair to him. Not a particularly funny one if you're a Hibs fan right enough.

Did he not like a Swindon Town fans post about coming 'back home' last season as well?

Seeing as he played with for them and they liked him i would doubt the guy meant much harm though probably was silly thing for him to do though .

Didn't Kenneh not do something as well ? . I suppose it just shows that players are humans too in they make mistakes and do daft things too .

One thing I do think though is when he was coming on for us against Aberdeen , he's coming on to do his best and once he has the green n white shirt on our fans shouldn't have boo 'd him . It didn't really help ! .

[Halmyre Hibee]

Good watch and sad some fans are feeling detached from the club. I’m a bit miserable about Hibs just now as well. The only way to reverse the negativity is to win football matches and give us a team to be proud of. Once we start doing that all other issues will then fall into place.

[Itsnoteasy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Seeing as he played with for them and they liked him i would doubt the guy meant much harm though probably was silly thing for him to do though .

Didn't Kenneh not do something as well ? . I suppose it just shows that players are humans too in they make mistakes and do daft things too .

One thing I do think though is when he was coming on for us against Aberdeen , he's coming on to do his best and once he has the green n white shirt on our fans shouldn't have boo 'd him . It didn't really help ! .

A Swindon fan tweeted " Time to come home Harry" To which he replied " Not wrong there" he later deleted the tweet and was disciplined by Hibs for it.
He had only been at Hibs for 2 months.
Good riddance wage thief.

[Bridge hibs]

Really enjoyed the topics, watched this morning, some great chat, cheers folks 👍

[hibeejeebies]

Love these episodes, keep them coming pls.

Good discussion and you do a fine job bringing it all together Matty.

[matty_f]

Cheers, they're really good episodes to record - we never know what we're going to get and it's great to hear from folk passionate about Hibs.

Always looking for new voices to come on the show as well, by the way...

[LongJohnBanger]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Cheers, they're really good episodes to record - we never know what we're going to get and it's great to hear from folk passionate about Hibs.

Always looking for new voices to come on the show as well, by the way...

Gives folk a break from listening to my pish more than twice a week

[Nicho87]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Love these episodes, keep them coming pls.

Good discussion and you do a fine job bringing it all together Matty.

I’ll second that. Great Hibs content and really enjoy these type of episodes.

Well done team longbangers

Great stuff even though the football team in question is horse

[Bridge hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Gives folk a break from listening to my pish more than twice a week

You guys do a great job mate, I also really enjoy the other guests and listening to all the varied opinions, theres always at least one who is on the same page as me 😁

[matty_f]

Ep 262 Saint and Easy

Out now wherever you get your podcasts!

💪 Back to winning ways
❓ Was the pressure off
😍 Marcondes free kick
🐿️ Boyle looking better
🧓🏼 Experience counts with Hanlon
Plus your talking points!

https://youtu.be/laepZQRGcHQ?si=EvBlOHI_aDoXdmyX

https://pod.fo/e/236a58

[matty_f]

We had our Thursday phone in tonight, with fans' views on the win at St Johnstone, the VAR review, player of the year and more.

https://pod.fo/e/237fb7

https://www.youtube.com/live/lLqBlRM...4Gu7Ex-Ky5cfDR

[BILLYHIBS]

Enjoyed that

Quite a good wee review of the St Johnstone game current talking points social media etc and what has been by all accounts a gash season

Agree with Colin Young Player Of The Year should be 21 years and younger some of the candidates are now first team veterans

Roll on the new season

Well worth a watch

[matty_f]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Enjoyed that

Quite a good wee review of the St Johnstone game current talking points social media etc and what has been by all accounts a gash season

Agree with Colin Young Player Of The Year should be 21 years and younger some of the candidates are now first team veterans

Roll on the new season

Well worth a watch

Thanks Billy. It's been good getting other folk on to give their thoughts on Hibs- hopefully the more we do them, the more people want to join in. I like the different perspectives, I don't always agree with everything but it always makes me think about the other side of the conversation.

[matty_f]

Ep 263 End it Now is out now!

This week:
Time to stop the excuses.
Is Monty's time up?
How do you fix the errors?
How big is the rebuild?
Wollacott fails his audition
Plus your talking points!

https://pod.fo/e/238d6d

https://youtu.be/LZu3Man8oIE?si=cT0EKss0jRan-9Hr

[Danderhall Hibs]

Good wee debate (argument?) about Monty at the start!

[matty_f]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Good wee debate (argument?) about Monty at the start!

I think that's classed as a "robust debate".

[bingo70]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Good wee debate (argument?) about Monty at the start!

I’m half way through it the now, will finish it when I’m driving later.

In the past I’ve been sympathetic to Johns argument but I’m no seeing it after that debate.

“We can’t keep sacking managers as we will just get the same results” seems to be the only argument for keeping him. I think John needs to take into account there’s different people and personalities being employed and it’s not just a case of one in-one out with the same result.

I know John looks in on here and posts some times, fair play to him for standing his ground, I felt there wasn’t much substance to his argument this time though.

[matty_f]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I’m half way through it the now, will finish it when I’m driving later.

In the past I’ve been sympathetic to Johns argument but I’m no seeing it after that debate.

“We can’t keep sacking managers as we will just get the same results” seems to be the only argument for keeping him. I think John needs to take into account there’s different people and personalities being employed and it’s not just a case of one in-one out with the same result.

I know John looks in on here and posts some times, fair play to him for standing his ground, I felt there wasn’t much substance to his argument this time though.

I've argued the point as well, and in John's defence there's a clear pattern of continued downward trajectory when we've sacked managers historically, so I can see where he's coming from.

The issue for me is that for all in in favour of giving a manager time, it needs to be the right guy. Persevering with someone for the sake of it is just going to cause more issues, and we're seeing nothing to suggest Monty is the right guy

[DaveF]

Had to stop listening when John came out with the usual 'we can't keep sacking managers' stuff. I dunno if he is just being contrary for the sake of debate but anyone who watches Hibs under NM and advocates keeping him for said reason is bordering on insanity.

[Since452]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I think that's classed as a "robust debate".

Listened to it and completely agree with your opinion on it. It was an interesting debate and John did make a good counter argument, even though it was wrong

[bingo70]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Had to stop listening when John came out with the usual 'we can't keep sacking managers' stuff. I dunno if he is just being contrary for the sake of debate but anyone who watches Hibs under NM and advocates keeping him for said reason is bordering on insanity.

Yeah, I was trying to be polite towards John as I like him on the podcast and I admire when someone stands their ground, despite being in the minority. It felt a wee bit like it was argumentative for the sake of an argument though.

Wee bit like you get on TalkSPORT and the likes when you know people don’t believe what they’re saying but they have to say it to generate discussion and wind people up. I’m not saying that’s what John was doing but it had that sort of feeling about the discussion today.

[Danderhall Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Yeah, I was trying to be polite towards John as I like him on the podcast and I admire when someone stands their ground, despite being in the minority. It felt a wee bit like it was argumentative for the sake of an argument though.

Wee bit like you get on TalkSPORT and the likes when you know people don’t believe what they’re saying but they have to say it to generate discussion and wind people up. I’m not saying that’s what John was doing but it had that sort of feeling about the discussion today.

I genuinely think he believes it and not putting an act on.