Sack or Keep

[Crab apple]

We have woefully underperformed this season. The manager should be fired.

[Pretty Boy]

As I said on one of the other threads it's a sack for me, with an air of real sadness about it.

I thought he was a good one and it was a bold choice. It's not turned out to be the case and we should be ruthless sooner rather than later. There are still far too many of the same issues now that there were back in September. You can't just ignore them in the name of 'giving' time or for perceived stability.

[marinello59]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

We have woefully underperformed this season. The manager should be fired.

And Kensell should leave as well.

[Murphys Touch]

I can believe this is my mindset but we’d be in top 6 and challenging for Europe with Lee J - who I didn’t rate in the slightest and thought he was a shocking appointment from the off.

Streaky Johnson would have more wins with this squad than Monty has - draws been a disaster and Monty has only himself to blame

[KazaHibs]

He's away. Either this week or end of season. It cannot last.

Monty, Kensell and McDermott must be crapping it!

[Hibrandenburg]

I don't call for managers to be sacked lightly but NM has to go. I can see no benefit in keeping him on until the end of the season, I'd rather give a new manager the chance to work with what we have before the next transfer window.

I've backed all our recent managers with the exception of Calderwood, Butcher and Maloney, NM is in that category.

[Stokesy's on fire]

Keep but empty Ben Kensell.

[NAE NOOKIE]

Sack him. The older I get the less patient I get and I just can't see him improving us even with a summer window.

Time for a new manager and an absolute clearing of the decks at HTC ... If that means SDG or anybody else having to move on then so be it.

[Hibees1973]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I can believe this is my mindset but we’d be in top 6 and challenging for Europe with Lee J - who I didn’t rate in the slightest and thought he was a shocking appointment from the off.

Streaky Johnson would have more wins with this squad than Monty has - draws been a disaster and Monty has only himself to blame

Johnson was a clown. But I agree with this.

Montgomery's lack of managerial experience at a decent level has been exposed. He is, in essence a rookie. Many of his worst decisions have been substitutions which when he made them, made no impression on the game or on numerous occasions made the result worse.

[Torto7062]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The thing is it is not even just the results. The football is absolutely eye bleeding!

I actually quite like the guy, I really wanted him to do well but he 100% needs to go.

This 100%

Was excited about seeing how we would do with....

[Quadrophenia]

I'm just shocked 10% want to keep him . Wish I could see what they do. Get rid by Monday .

[Jim44]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

If we sack the manager the whole coaching team need to be binned too.
Maybe the club need to stop spending money on hospitality cos there won't be many people wanting to go now !

I think this is a very important. The emphasis is on the wrong priorities. Who cares about the fabric and quality of service when the product on the pitch consistently fails to deliver?

[Zazu62]

Sacked. And that includes David Gray and the rest of the coaching staff. Enough is enough.

[Greenio]

I voted keep. I think he'll go though and thats not a mistake.

Get someone in quick though and i want someone other than McInnes and I 100% dont want Lennon

[Frazerbob]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I think this is a very important. The emphasis is on the wrong priorities. Who cares about the fabric and quality of service when the product on the pitch consistently fails to deliver?

The 2 are not linked. We can have great hospitality that will generate funds for years to come AND a team worthy of the club on the pitch. We've spent more of the squad this season than ever before. Lack of funds to the playing pool is not the reason for the latest shambles......it's having the wrong manager in place to work with that squad.

[leith lynx]

Sadly there has been no improvement, not a single chink of light. Hopefully a new experienced manager is in place by June, fresh ideas and some decent defenders. Let Bill Foley call the shots, we can't keep on drifting along like this.

[He's here!]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

SDG should be gone as well. Part of how many management team failures now ?

Always done a solid job on the numerous occasions he's stepped into caretaker charge tho. Maybe now's his time to prove himself. Naismith's turned out well for Hearts after initially looking a dud in his first managerial role.

[sean04]

Not just monty. Clear out upstairs and behind the scenes aswell. He's under to much pressure now. Will be a repeat of LJ if we start next season poor

[Donegal Hibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Always done a solid job on the numerous occasions he's stepped into caretaker charge tho. Maybe now's his time to prove himself. Naismith's turned out well for Hearts after initially looking a dud in his first managerial role.

I voted keep . Though think he might go after today . If he did I'd give it to SDG until the end of the season. Chris Hogg would be another one I'd look at or a foreign manager like Aberdeen have .

Any names that have came up I see problems with , McInnes will eventually be turned on due to the style of football like Ross was . Lennon we have tried and it ended up a total disaster . Robinson again football style and I'd far rather give it to SDG over Murray or the Airdrie boss who's also been mentioned too .

If the manager does go I hope Kensell follows him out the door as he's been totally unprofessional in the past and is part of our current problems imo .

[green day]

10 % want to keep him.

Its done, imv

[ruskers]

Utterly clueless excuse for a manager , sack him .

[Chorley Hibee]

It should be announced tonight.

Kensall should be leaving with him.

[supermcginn]

Sack, he should have been gone after losing last week to a dreadful St Johnstone team managed by a dinosaur.

[Mango Man]

I'm all up for giving managers a bit of time, if there is something to get behind, but there really has been nothing of note with Monty, a lot of things have not went his way this season, but he has failed to get on any kind of winning run going at any point, we have been fragile all season.

Massive clear out needed......again.

[Cabbage-Patch]

Sack him tonight, we owe him nothing so why wait until Monday like they usually do

[john rossi]

8 wins from 29 matches tells its own story afraid to say his time is up jan window badly needed 2 experienced defenders non brought in other than Triantis.

[WestCoastHibby]

Get him gone and sadly i include others in the staff too

[HIBS NUTS]

Keep

[ChuckNor]

He’s got to go. Unforgivable record in charge. Truly awful.

[Crazyhorse]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Sack him tonight, we owe him nothing so why wait until Monday like they usually do

I would agree with this but I suspect we have no one lined up.