The Sportscene Thread

[CMac1988]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

That was a stonewall penalty for Aberdeen yesterday

There was people saying yesterday Hanlon got the ball

Wit...

Yeah stone-waller. I'd say Boyle should have got a penalty in the 1st half though so tough cookies.

[Dancehibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Yeah stone-waller. I'd say Boyle should have got a penalty in the 1st half though so tough cookies.

Agree. Also, last season up at Pittodrie boyler should have got a stonewaller

[PatHead]

And Mackay Steven should have been sent off.

[Dancehibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

And Mackay Steven should have been sent off.

Not for me. Booking was fair

[PatHead]

Not sure if that should have been a sending off for Killie

[Spike Mandela]

I shouted to McInnes that his penalty claim was the clearest dive you'd ever see.....Oops.....he just laughed.

[O'Rourke3]

At the game from our angle Paul goes in, ball moves, then player falls over. Looked like a great tackle. Slo mo and reruns show it should have been a pen. Didn't need a replay to see we should have had a pen when Consadine pushes Boyle off the ball in the box.

Sent from my F8331 using Tapatalk

[brog]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

At the game from our angle Paul goes in, ball moves, then player falls over. Looked like a great tackle. Slo mo and reruns show it should have been a pen. Didn't need a replay to see we should have had a pen when Consadine pushes Boyle off the ball in the box.

Sent from my F8331 using Tapatalk

Exactly, clear hand pushing MB in the back.

[My_Wife_Camille]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

On Hibs tv he clearly gets the ball

Was my opinion too but having seen the Sportscene highlights you can see it should have been a penalty.

It’s easy to see how the red has got it wrong, especially from his angle but it’s the wrong call nonetheless. What I don’t understand is how he never gave an Aberdeen corner

[matty_f]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Was my opinion too but having seen the Sportscene highlights you can see it should have been a penalty.

It’s easy to see how the red has got it wrong, especially from his angle but it’s the wrong call nonetheless. What I don’t understand is how he never gave an Aberdeen corner

I don't think the ref thought that Hanlon took anything of the attacker.

Was May onside though? He looked a yard offside from where I was sitting, haven't watched the replay yet though.

[I'm_cabbaged]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Was my opinion too but having seen the Sportscene highlights you can see it should have been a penalty.

It’s easy to see how the red has got it wrong, especially from his angle but it’s the wrong call nonetheless. What I don’t understand is how he never gave an Aberdeen corner

Will have to have a look. But if one angle shows he touches the ball, he’s touched the ball 😉

[JimBHibees]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Not for me. Booking was fair

No chance

[My_Wife_Camille]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Will have to have a look. But if one angle shows he touches the ball, he’s touched the ball 😉

I’ve not seen an angle on Hibs TV Or otherwise that shows him touch the ball. I’ve seen a few that certainly makes it look like it but if you see the angle from behind the goals on BBC’s Highlights you see the Aberdeen player touches the ball away before Hanlons foot is anywhere near

Was a very difficult one to get but imo we got a bit lucky in the end

[Glory Lurker]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I’ve not seen an angle on Hibs TV Or otherwise that shows him touch the ball. I’ve seen a few that certainly makes it look like it but if you see the angle from behind the goals on BBC’s Highlights you see the Aberdeen player touches the ball away before Hanlons foot is anywhere near

Was a very difficult one to get but imo we got a bit lucky in the end

I thought it looked clear on Alba footage that Hanlon got it
I guess Sportscene would use same?

[noz]

Albas coverage is pretty basic, Hanlons missed and caught the guy, stone waller. Camilles right.
Need to get a new telly mate! 🤤

[Glory Lurker]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Albas coverage is pretty basic, Hanlons missed and caught the guy, stone waller. Camilles right.
Need to get a new telly mate! 🤤

Judging by how many posts disagree with me, you might be right!

[Ringothedog]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Not for me. Booking was fair

Yeh nutting someone in the chin is okay. That cheating little runt should have been hung,drawn and quartered for his deliberate assault on Ryan Porteous

[angus hibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

That was a stonewall penalty for Aberdeen yesterday

There was people saying yesterday Hanlon got the ball

Wit...

Agree but think the way Ferguson threw his hands in the air when falling didn’t do him any favours.

[Iggy Pope]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Albas coverage is pretty basic, Hanlons missed and caught the guy, stone waller. Camilles right.
Need to get a new telly mate! 🤤

Camilles wrong. Hanlon poked his foot in towards the ball, fellah dived into his foot. Never a penalty and the only decision Dallas got right all day. Had the perfect view from my position and without any gaelic gibberish in my ear either.

[Inconsequential]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I thought it looked clear on Alba footage that Hanlon got it
I guess Sportscene would use same?

I agree entirely the BBC ALBA replay clearly showed Paul Hanlon touched the ball and the commentators agreed! It was a blatant dive both spectacular and hilarious as I have already stated on the forum. Contrary to common belief BBC ALBA has excellent coverage of Scottish Football. Yesterday at half-time there was an interview with Steve Cowan which was interesting. Does anyone trust what BBC Scotland transmits anymore?

[Inconsequential]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Camilles wrong. Hanlon poked his foot in towards the ball, fellah dived into his foot. Never a penalty and the only decision Dallas got right all day. Had the perfect view from my position and without any gaelic gibberish in my ear either.

Indeed it was never a penalty in Gaelic (gibberish or no) or English!

[Tornadoes70]

Not a penalty for me re Hanlon, the dons player made a meal of it. Certainly a case for GMS to be sent off but it was inconclusive for me that the contact was intentionally meant to hurt big Ryan.

The worst decision by far for me was the one against Killie in favour of the yams. Killie boss Clarke had every right to be outraged as that was never a sending off. Debatable whether it was even a foul. Collum did the yams a huge favour there and gave them a massive helping hand.

Roll on next week. Livi away I think and should be an opportunity to get all three points.

[Feed McGraw]

Said at the match Paul got a toe on the ball although some around me disagreed - I`ve seen nothing on the highlights to change my mind.

[Glory Lurker]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Camilles wrong.

I'd have expressed it as "Glory Lurker's right" myself, but there you go. :-)

[My_Wife_Camille]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Camilles wrong. Hanlon poked his foot in towards the ball, fellah dived into his foot. Never a penalty and the only decision Dallas got right all day. Had the perfect view from my position and without any gaelic gibberish in my ear either.

The guy did not dive into his foot at all. His foot was planted before Hanlon made contact from the side of him

First pictures show the Aberdeen player making contact with ball ahead of Hanlon. Hanlons left foot is still in motion moving towards the ball at this point
E0451637-C785-48AB-899A-936D93EB4266.jpg


The second picture shows Hanlon making contact with the player having missed the ball
F2D7D22D-8AFF-4294-9C47-E0FA77F9180B.jpg


I thought it was the right call at the time too and so I can absolutely see why you think it was but looking at the replays it’s definitely one we got away with. Still, they got away with one on Boyle which McInnes was strangely quiet about

[RyeSloan]

Ach it was a pen all day long...Hanlon never touches the ball.

But Boylers was a pen as well...clear shove in the back.

Killie red was never a sending off either!

Finally how woeful did StMirren look in the ‘highlights’ of their game. Wow!

[Jack Hackett]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Said at the match Paul got a toe on the ball although some around me disagreed - I`ve seen nothing on the highlights to change my mind.

Me neither. I see a clear change of direction for the ball after Hanlon toes it and before Ferguson stretches for it, regardless of what the commentator says... but then he hadn't watched it as many times as I have before he said it

Edit

I've just had another go, and have to admit that having finally managed to stop frame at the right moment, at 2:31 in. Penalty!

[Sylar]

I've been in no doubt for some time, but yesterday highlighted that Willie Collum is no longer fit to referee football at the top level.

Some of his decisions were absolutely honking, no more so than the red card for Dicker. Both Killie and Hearts can probably also feel aggrieved not to have been given a couple of penalties each too. Sadly, the only person who'll get in trouble will be Steve Clarke for calling out Collum after the game.

[My_Wife_Camille]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Me neither. I see a clear change of direction for the ball after Hanlon toes it and before Ferguson stretches for it, regardless of what the commentator says... but then he hadn't watched it as many times as I have before he said it

Edit

I've just had another go, and have to admit that having finally managed to stop frame at the right moment, at 2:31 in. Penalty!

Welcome to the dark side!

[green day]

I have put the Hanlon / Ferguson incident on slo mo a few times this morning - the ball changes direction when Hanlon gets a touch, it was not a penalty, regardless if what Mikey Stewart and Thommo think.

He unquestionably played the ball first - why a corner not given I just put down to ***** officials.