If you could keep only one loanee at ER next season who would it be?

[G B Young]

Overall I'd probably opt for Scott Allan as I think he was the driving force behind our second half of the season surge, but it's hard to rule out Kamberi who looks a top, top player. I also REALLY like Barker and think he has bags of potential to improve massively. Maclaren has proved to be a great wee poacher and again, under Lennon, he would only get better.

[Sir David Gray]

Kamberi but it's very hard to choose.

PS - You forgot Faycal Rherras.

[greenginger]

Kamberi, not had a forward like him in a long time.

[Lendo]

Went with Flo, but really I don't want any of them to leave. Love this current squad.

[hibee_girl]

Kamberi

[Beefster]

Scott Allan. Can I not choose four though?!

[TheGreenMan]

Kamberi 14 apps (9 goals)
Maclaren 15 apps (8 goals)

I really hope we can keep these two. They'd both be pushing 20 goals if we had them for the full season.

*Stats from Wikipedia so not sure if 100% correct*

Edit - if only 1 then got to be Flo

[JeMeSouviens]

1. Flo
2. Allan
3. McLaren
4. Barker

... but they're all worth keeping.

[Curried]

Kamberi. Just the most complete forward we've had in my time watching Hibs.
Superb work rate and physical presence, but also has the technical skills and shooting ability to take it to the highest levels in the game.

[G B Young]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Kamberi. Just the most complete forward we've had in my time watching Hibs.
Superb work rate and physical presence, but also has the technical skills and shooting ability to take it to the highest levels in the game.

He's also a guy who could potentially bring us a mighty fine transfer fee were he to continue to perform the way he's been doing. I'd be very surprised if we aren't doing everything possible to sign him up.

If we can keep Scott Allan, I'd hope he might be a player who would stay at ER for years to come after realising the error of his ways when he left us too hastily last time round.

[MrSmith]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

1. Flo
2. Allan
3. McLaren
4. Barker

... but they're all worth keeping.

Yes! I'm being optimistic too :D

[aljo7-0]

I voted Kamberi but could happily have any of them back and was almost picking Scott Allan.

[G B Young]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Kamberi but it's very hard to choose.

PS - You forgot Faycal Rherras.

Indeed. Completely forgot about him. What became of him? Did he turn out for the development squad to get some game time or has his loan spell simply passed by all but unnoticed?

[WeeRussell]

I'd like all 4 please. Kamberi in particular up top, and if more improvement to come from Barker he could be some asset.

However, Allan would be up there with my picks to keep from our whole squad. Different class.

[G B Young]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I'd like all 4 please. Kamberi in particular up top, and if more improvement to come from Barker he could be some asset.

However, Allan would be up there with my picks to keep from our whole squad. Different class.

Agreed. With Dylan away and McGinn likely to go, the three players I'd most like to keep out of those whose future is up for grabs would be Allan, Kamberi and Barker.

[My_Wife_Camille]

Both for me

[Stranraer]

Allan for me, he has been outstanding recently.

[Brightside]

2 of them wont be loanees next season. Unless there is a major change.

[Hibeewilly]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

1. Flo
2. Allan
3. McLaren
4. Barker

... but they're all worth keeping.

I think we'll keep them all..........no info......just a gut feeling

[WeeRussell]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I think we'll keep them all..........no info......just a gut feeling

I think we'll be doing damn well to keep half of them.

[ChooseLife]

Kamberi and Alan for sure.

I'd really go for trying to get McClaren too, I don't think Kamberi would be as effective without him, they play at their best together.

[Fergus52]

Couldn't vote, too tough to choose between Kamberi and Allan.

Don't want to jynx it either

[we are hibs]

How old is Kamberi? If he signs we should be doing all we can do make it a decent length of contract. Last thing we want is a 2 year deal, he bangs in the goals but we are forced to move him on to get a decent fee; but less than what we'd get if we was contracted anther year.

MacLaren has grew on me massively as time has went on. Wasn't so sure at first but he, Scott Allan and Kamberi link up so well.


Scott Allan is Scott Allan. You know what your going to get. But what's impressed me is that the first time he was here he was labelled lazy and wouldn't help the midfield/defence out by tracking back. But second time round his work ethic has been brilliant at times. I think he realised he had a point to prove and had making up to do and has done it.


Barker is a great talent with so much potential if he can find a consistent final ball. He's naturally compared to Boyle and Sproule because of his pace but he's different as in he can slow down and beat a man rather than just burning past them. Boyle struggled with his final ball for a couple of years but has came on leaps and bounds and has now started to put in some brilliant crosses. Alright he still fluffs a few but he's massively improved.



If I had to pick one it'd be Kamberi because I don't think I've quite ever seen such a complete striker at hibs. He has pace, good touch, physically strong, skillfull and can finish.

[Speedy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

1. Flo
2. Allan
3. McLaren
4. Barker

... but they're all worth keeping.

Agree 100%

[Lancs Harp]

I voted for Scotty, but lets face it they were four pretty decent loan signings.

[snooky]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

1. Flo
2. Allan
3. McLaren
4. Barker

... but they're all worth keeping.

1. Allan
2. Flo
3. Barker
4. McLaren

... ditto re all worth keeping

[Mick O'Rourke]

Decisions ! decisions !
How good have they all been for the team.
It was a bit of eeny meeny miny moe.
Then went for Kamberi.(close one wae Scott)

Maybe not as stylish and silky, but he reminds me a wee bit of the late great Alan Gordon


Now can we get a "wee fat barrel" to partner Flo?!

Thats hoping he signs,of course

[blackpoolhibs]

return.jpg

[Phil MaGlass]

John McGinn

[frazeHFC]

Over the years we've had so many loans that have been useless, but lately they've been brilliant. Went for Kamberi but it was tight, would love them all back.