Is there a clique on here?

[NAE NOOKIE]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Aye you get to wear a Hearts shirt for a week.

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Reported & nae need.

Thank you Silverhibee ...... I felt so dirty after that comment I couldn't even respond

[NAE NOOKIE]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Banned hopefully.

[SRHibs]

In terms of the moderation it’s clear that posts are dealt with subjectively due to the lack of consistency. The forum is of a good quality though so it’s not a huge issue.

[SRHibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

#metoo

You know I’m kidding right?

[Pretty Boy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

In terms of the moderation it’s clear that posts are dealt with subjectively due to the lack of consistency. The forum is of a good quality though so it’s not a huge issue.

In what way is there a lack of consistency?

That seems to be based on a few posters making the assumption that they have had a warning for something that another hasn't. Warnings are given privately so no one is really aware of who else has been warned or what for.

[SRHibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

In what way is there a lack of consistency?

That seems to be based on a few posters making the assumption that they have had a warning for something that another hasn't. Warnings are given privately so no one is really aware of who else has been warned or what for.

Based on what the moderator in question perceives as a break of the rules. For example, I posted a really good article about the Scottish game a few weeks ago and it was removed because it had the ‘f’ word in it - within the article, not the link or title. I’ve seen plenty of worse things on here and lots of adult jokes which are much worse than a single use of an expletive. I just think each moderator’s own sensitivities play a part in their decision-making, thus the lack of overall consistency.

[Keith_M]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

In what way is there a lack of consistency?

That seems to be based on a few posters making the assumption that they have had a warning for something that another hasn't. Warnings are given privately so no one is really aware of who else has been warned or what for.

I don't know about official warnings or bans but some Admins seem more, let's just say 'easy going', than others. I'm quite happy to have a bit of banter with you and most of the other admins, but some I wouldn't even risk responding to, unless I feel really brave that day

It's just a fact of life that everybody is different, so not exactly a shock.

[Mr White]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Based on what the moderator in question perceives as a break of the rules. For example, I posted a really good article about the Scottish game a few weeks ago and it was removed because it had the ‘f’ word in it - within the article, not the link or title. I’ve seen plenty of worse things on here and lots of adult jokes which are much worse than a single use of an expletive. I just think each moderator’s own sensitivities play a part in their decision-making, thus the lack of overall consistency.

So in the next installment of .net mythbusters...

I didn't delete that thread but the admin who did was absolutely right to. I've just had a look and the main image in the article it links to is a pornhub screenshot that Inverness CT accidentally posted on their twitter feed.

While different admins do have differing opinions to some degree about what's unacceptable... I can guarantee you that all of us would have deleted that link.

Some may have spent a bit longer than others staring at it first but that's mostly irrelevant

[jacomo]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

In terms of the moderation it’s clear that posts are dealt with subjectively due to the lack of consistency. The forum is of a good quality though so it’s not a huge issue.

No need to bring in VAR then? Phew.

[SRHibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

So in the next installment of .net mythbusters...

I didn't delete that thread but the admin who did was absolutely right to. I've just had a look and the main image in the article it links to is a pornhub screenshot that Inverness CT accidentally posted on their twitter feed.

While different admins do have differing opinions to some degree about what's unacceptable... I can guarantee you that all of us would have deleted that link.

Some may have spent a bit longer than others staring at it first but that's mostly irrelevant

Fairplay I thought it was for the language, I take it back. Still seen a lot of iffy stuff still standing though.

[hibsbollah]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

So in the next installment of .net mythbusters...

I didn't delete that thread but the admin who did was absolutely right to. I've just had a look and the main image in the article it links to is a pornhub screenshot that Inverness CT accidentally posted on their twitter feed.

While different admins do have differing opinions to some degree about what's unacceptable... I can guarantee you that all of us would have deleted that link.

Some may have spent a bit longer than others staring at it first but that's mostly irrelevant

Hibs net admins in 'tempted to have a ham shank while carrying out their duties' shock.

[Mr White]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Fairplay I thought it was for the language, I take it back. Still seen a lot of iffy stuff still standing though.

Well unless you can think of another example involving hard core pornography then I'm not in the least bit interested

[Pretty Boy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I don't know about official warnings or bans but some Admins seem more, let's just say 'easy going', than others. I'm quite happy to have a bit of banter with you and most of the other admins, but some I wouldn't even risk responding to, unless I feel really brave that day

It's just a fact of life that everybody is different, so not exactly a shock.

I think there's an element of 'no win' for us when it comes to everyday interaction. We used to use the HNA accounts for everything 'official' but people didn't like that and we got called 'faceless' and various other things. We started just using our own accounts for everything and there was confusion about our personal opinions being a 'party line' and we were called 'puppets' and were apparently working for David Forsyth; I'd go as far as to say in soem cases it got quite nasty and so on so we had to bring back the HNA accounts. Some use them and some don't.

I know you acknowledge everyone is different and I'm sure some admins do brush stuff off easier than others but that's the same as any interaction between posters. There are some I know I can have a wee dig at and others I wouldn't bother. When it comes to 'enforcing' the fundamental rules of the site though I think we are pretty consistent, it's why there is a group and not one individual deciding these things as it avoids personal vendettas or whatever influencing decisions too much.

As I always say if people feel stuff is sliding under the radar or a rule has been broken then report it and we'll look at it. Contrary to what some may thing I don't read every page of the site every day and neither does anyone else so some stuff is inevitably missed.

[SRHibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Well unless you can think of another example involving hard core pornography then I'm not in the least bit interested

It was all over the place on 21/05/16!

[One Day Soon]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Hibs net admins in 'tempted to have a ham shank while carrying out their duties' shock.

That's a whole new group. Onanistique clique.

[BS44]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I responded to this allegation last night then thought better of it and deleted my post as we don't discuss bans publcly. However this 'banned for nothing' is going to become a fact and the truth is quite different.

There were 2 warnings issued, both for insulting other members, one of which involved bypassing the swear filter to call another user a certain word beginning with C. Users get a message informing them they have been warned. The 'joke' in question was an absolute disgrace, if that's your humour then fair enough but it's not getting broadcast on a site we try to keep relatively family friendly.

All 3 incidents were in a short space of time.

For goodness sake PB.

If you had left your post up last night then it's entirely possible that I would only have made a complete fud of myself for one day rather than two.

Please accept my apologies for talking nonsense.

[Haymaker]

[The Green Goblin]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

You know I’m kidding right?

Of course. Just thought it was funny because you said after April 2002 and I was May 2002.

[The Green Goblin]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I think there's an element of 'no win' for us when it comes to everyday interaction. We used to use the HNA accounts for everything 'official' but people didn't like that and we got called 'faceless' and various other things. We started just using our own accounts for everything and there was confusion about our personal opinions being a 'party line' and we were called 'puppets' and were apparently working for David Forsyth; I'd go as far as to say in soem cases it got quite nasty and so on so we had to bring back the HNA accounts. Some use them and some don't.

I know you acknowledge everyone is different and I'm sure some admins do brush stuff off easier than others but that's the same as any interaction between posters. There are some I know I can have a wee dig at and others I wouldn't bother. When it comes to 'enforcing' the fundamental rules of the site though I think we are pretty consistent, it's why there is a group and not one individual deciding these things as it avoids personal vendettas or whatever influencing decisions too much.

As I always say if people feel stuff is sliding under the radar or a rule has been broken then report it and we'll look at it. Contrary to what some may thing I don't read every page of the site every day and neither does anyone else so some stuff is inevitably missed.

I have had a couple of “words in my ear” via PM from admins in my time. All very reasonable, clearly explained and fair enough. Think they do a good job (for pricks anyway) and it makes it a great board to read andget involved.

[Hermit Crab]

If' you've not got over 15'000 post and a home and away season ticket you're tinpot.

[ancient hibee]

Does the ITK clique have its own club Room?

[Haymaker]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Does the ITK clique have its own club Room?

The London Hibs Supporters certainly do.

[One Day Soon]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

If' you've not got over 15'000 post and a home and away season ticket you're tinpot.

Automatic Unique and Antique Clique memberships.

Plus blocked, reported and deary me.

And you become the second .net openly Venn poster. Bollah beat you to first place by apparently outing himself with dual Newsweek and Gallique Clique credentials while monstering poor, cliqueless snooky.

You've also launched a new non-rhyming tinpot clique that you're not even a member of!

A stunning performance for a single sentence post.

[Hibrandenburg]

I've blocked everyone else on here and created the ultimate clique.

[One Day Soon]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I've blocked everyone else on here and created the ultimate clique.

You've disappeared up your own clique?

[Keith_M]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I think there's an element of 'no win' for us when it comes to everyday interaction. We used to use the HNA accounts for everything 'official' but people didn't like that and we got called 'faceless' and various other things. We started just using our own accounts for everything and there was confusion about our personal opinions being a 'party line' and we were called 'puppets' and were apparently working for David Forsyth; I'd go as far as to say in soem cases it got quite nasty and so on so we had to bring back the HNA accounts. Some use them and some don't.

I know you acknowledge everyone is different and I'm sure some admins do brush stuff off easier than others but that's the same as any interaction between posters. There are some I know I can have a wee dig at and others I wouldn't bother. When it comes to 'enforcing' the fundamental rules of the site though I think we are pretty consistent, it's why there is a group and not one individual deciding these things as it avoids personal vendettas or whatever influencing decisions too much.

As I always say if people feel stuff is sliding under the radar or a rule has been broken then report it and we'll look at it. Contrary to what some may thing I don't read every page of the site every day and neither does anyone else so some stuff is inevitably missed.

PB, I've posted before that I really appreciate the work you guys do, and that's still the case. It can't be an easy job.

[Hibrandenburg]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

You've disappeared up your own clique?

Pretty much like this thread, the Main Board clique/Admin ****ers have closed ranks and moved it to the dog house.

[NAE NOOKIE]

The dug out !! ..... the dug out !!! .......... First time in 11 years I get a thread to go over 2 pages and you send it to the f'ing DUG OUT not even the Holy Ground !!!.

Who says there's nae clique on here

[snooky]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The dug out !! ..... the dug out !!! .......... First time in 11 years I get a thread to go over 2 pages and you send it to the f'ing DUG OUT not even the Holy Ground !!!.

Who says there's nae clique on here

Who let the dug out?

[BroxburnHibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The dug out !! ..... the dug out !!! .......... First time in 11 years I get a thread to go over 2 pages and you send it to the f'ing DUG OUT not even the Holy Ground !!!.

Who says there's nae clique on here

Cheer up! We've moved it to the clique forum