Dylan mcgeouch

[Smartie]

If his performance drops, we can think about playing silly beggars with his contract offer.

There's an offer on the table, he's playing well in a team that's playing well.

Patience chaps.

If he stays, great. If he moves on, so do we.

[jacomo]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

If his performance drops, we can think about playing silly beggars with his contract offer.

There's an offer on the table, he's playing well in a team that's playing well.

Patience chaps.

If he stays, great. If he moves on, so do we.

The 2nd offer is on the table.

Just have to let this one play out.

[1648]

Have not looked to closely at all the posts but if D wants to leave. Hey ho it happens at all clubs. He is still a 21/05/2016 and that’s all that matters for me.

[007]

Have any of the departees of the class of 21.5.16 gone on to bigger and better things? Niklas Gunnarsson's club Djurgården finished 3rd and have qualified for the Europa League so arguably he has, but his departure was due to him reaching the end of his loan spell. Same with Hendo who had only just got his move to Bari so it's too early to say if it's a good move or not.

Hopefully Dylan will realise how good he has it with Hibs and signs the extension.

[JimBHibees]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I get what you, underscore and others are saying about him I just don't happen to agree with it. I've never once said he's not a decent player, and I've watched enough football over my lifetime to appreciate a team needs different types of players who complement each other. I just don't get the love in with him and feel his actual contribution in a game is far less than is made out. Keeping possession is of course a good thing, but taking it off the back four and passing it straight back doesn't get me waxing lyrical about what a great player he is - and I feel he does that too often. He has the ability to do more, when he gets in a decent position I want to see him take more responsibility, drive into the box, take a shot, not take the easy option as he usually does.

You refer to him as a quarterback but a quarterback is the main man, the guy who makes things happen where it matters, that's not and never has been McGeouch. I'd say that would be better attributed to Scott Allan, but that's a totally different discussion.

As I've said before I know I'm in the minority but while he plays in his current manner I'll never understand why he gets such high praise, in the same way those who rate him so highly will not understand why I don't feel that way.

Watch back the first derby of the season he was amazing that night. Totally ran the game.

[Eaststand]

I may be imagining it, but I thought somebody posted fairly recently that we should expect good news soon about Dylan.
Maybe they could supply an update ?

GGTTH

[FilipinoHibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I may be imagining it, but I thought somebody posted fairly recently that we should expect good news soon about Dylan.
Maybe they could supply an update ?

GGTTH

Yes I had that dream too!

[southern hibby]

Spoke to him in Portugal and asked if he was staying he said he really wasn’t sure as it was down to his agent. Now not sure if he genuinely expected us to believe that or it was just a get out of jail free card from the conversation but are footballers that thick that they leave decisions like this to their agents? Or do they think we’re thick enough to buy this excuse?

Really hope he stays but not holding out much hope.


GGTTH

[calumhibee1]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Watch back the first derby of the season he was amazing that night. Totally ran the game.

He was unbelievable that night.

[Stuart93]

Strange to think we might be without mcginn, mcgeouch and (obviously) Allan next season, as well as being without our two current strikers, we might sign kamberi...another rebuilding job needed.

[007]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Strange to think we might be without mcginn, mcgeouch and (obviously) Allan next season, as well as being without our two current strikers, we might sign kamberi...another rebuilding job needed.

In Lennon we trust... except when it comes to keeping the heid on the touchline.

[jeffers]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Watch back the first derby of the season he was amazing that night. Totally ran the game.

Totally agree, in one of my earlier posts I said he was outstanding that night, playing in much more advanced position. It's the best I've seen him in a Hibs jersey. That's my main issue with him he has that ability to effect a game where it matters, just doesn't do that enough imo. To the poster who suggested he plays to the instructions from the manager was he told that night to push forward and every other game to sit deep ??

[J-C]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

We’re not telling him he’s not wanted - there’s an offer on the table for him.

He’s kinda saying he doesn’t want to be here next year by not signing.

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

It's difficult to see why he would regard the offer being withdrawn as anything else.

Right now McGeouch hasn't made his mind up because he wants to keep his options open. Let's hope he makes the right choice when he does decide.

It's a difficult situation as Hibs have upped their offer which is now on the table, I'd be disappointed if he didn't sign and went elsewhere just for a few extra pennies. I think maybe a wee push from Lennon and Leeann explaining that if he's unwilling to sign he must let Hibs know his plans soon so we as a club can plan for the forthcoming season.

[JimBHibees]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

It's a difficult situation as Hibs have upped their offer which is now on the table, I'd be disappointed if he didn't sign and went elsewhere just for a few extra pennies. I think maybe a wee push from Lennon and Leeann explaining that if he's unwilling to sign he must let Hibs know his plans soon so we as a club can plan for the forthcoming season.

Sounds like a bit of game playing no doubt by the agent to get a better deal we will just need to see how it goes.

[Stevie Reid]

Can understand him waiting, but it is a risk. With us being guaranteed top 6 he's going to have (provided he stays free from injury) a chance to play in more big games and show to us (or prospective employers) that he's worth even more than what's on the table. If he plays a part in getting us to third, and us getting a much larger chunk of money from that, we may well increase the offer more.

Things are in his favour, but if he were to get injured, he could be really stuck.

[madhatter]

Good player but not as good as he possibly thinks. One thing is for sure is - play well for Hibs and you get noticed, play well for another team and your career can stagnate. So, while McGinn and McGeouch would be massive losses, we'd move on and hopefully identify players with equal or greater talent.

Being critical of them both, when they both have poor games they can be posted missing and that is a huge problem if they are playing as a 2 in the middle. Bartley at least challenges and puts himself about, against Kilmarnock McGinn couldn't get close enough to tackle and McGeouch could barely pass to his own teammates. They both need to improve their impact on games when they are having a bad game. Disappearing isn't the answer. I'm sure they know this but I hope an agent isn't influencing them into thinking that they are some wonder player. They are both good but I doubt Real Madrid are interested.