Players ratings v Thistle

[erin go bragh]

Any chance some of they brilliant 2000 plus fans could post some ratings .
Thanks in advance.

[1875M]

Marciano 8 - Some great saves, especially the 1 v 1 and the one in the 2nd half

Ambrose 6.5 - Some dodgy moments but Ok overall
Hanlon 8 - Thought he was fab - composed and a very good performance
McGregor 7 - First game back in a while,, I was talking my pal saying he didnt't look up to match speed in the first 5 minues but adjusted quickly, good performance.

Boyle 8 - Maybe a bit generous but I thought he was fantastic today, caused real problems
McGeough 7 - Good again
Slivka 6 - Anonymous today I thought, especially in the 1st
Bartley 7 - Broke up play well and a typical Bartley performance
Stevenson 7 - Won all his 50/50s today and a good perfromance again


Stokes 6 - Thought he was OK, nothing special though
Murray 6 - Done all his usual running, did OK i thought

everyone agree with that?

[LaMotta]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Marciano 8 - Some great saves, especially the 1 v 1 and the one in the 2nd half

Ambrose 6.5 - Some dodgy moments but Ok overall
Hanlon 8 - Thought he was fab - composed and a very good performance
McGregor 7 - First game back in a while,, I was talking my pal saying he didnt't look up to match speed in the first 5 minues but adjusted quickly, good performance.

Boyle 8 - Maybe a bit generous but I thought he was fantastic today, caused real problems
McGeough 7 - Good again
Slivka 6 - Anonymous today I thought, especially in the 1st
Bartley 7 - Broke up play well and a typical Bartley performance
Stevenson 7 - Won all his 50/50s today and a good perfromance again


Stokes 6 - Thought he was OK, nothing special though
Murray 6 - Done all his usual running, did OK i thought

everyone agree with that?

Agree mainly but thought Stevenson was MOM for us. So he has to get an 8 for me.

Rocky's save with his foot was outstanding. He has been a matchwinner for us at least twice this year.

[Comiston Hibee]

Can’t disagree too much with OP
Good to see Darren back; always feels
More confident when he is playing

[Springbank]

Think that's a decent summary

We had Hanlon as m.o.m

Slivka 4/10 today. So much more to come from him but today passed him by.

Barker and oli Shaw both very decent off the bench too.

[Hiber-nation]

Boyle, Stevenson, Hanlon, McGeouch, McGregor, Marciano all very good.

Slivka didn't get involved enough and and Stokes wasn't great.

[greenlex]

Really disappointed with Slivka today. A chance to make his mark and just didn’t.
On the flip side very impressed with Shaw’s contribution.

[Springbank]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Really disappointed with Slivka today. A chance to make his mark and just didn’t.
On the flip side very impressed with Shaw’s contribution.

Agree 100%

Shaw has a lot of class

[Steve20]

Stevenson would be my man of the match.

[GlesgaeHibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Really disappointed with Slivka today. A chance to make his mark and just didn’t.
On the flip side very impressed with Shaw’s contribution.

Agree, although slivka did better 2nd half but still not great. Stevenson had a very good game today.

[theonlywayisup]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Marciano 8 - Some great saves, especially the 1 v 1 and the one in the 2nd half

Ambrose 6.5 - Some dodgy moments but Ok overall
Hanlon 8 - Thought he was fab - composed and a very good performance
McGregor 7 - First game back in a while,, I was talking my pal saying he didnt't look up to match speed in the first 5 minues but adjusted quickly, good performance.

Boyle 8 - Maybe a bit generous but I thought he was fantastic today, caused real problems
McGeough 7 - Good again
Slivka 6 - Anonymous today I thought, especially in the 1st
Bartley 7 - Broke up play well and a typical Bartley performance
Stevenson 7 - Won all his 50/50s today and a good perfromance again


Stokes 6 - Thought he was OK, nothing special though
Murray 6 - Done all his usual running, did OK i thought

everyone agree with that?

Overall, I agree. But thought Ambrose was much more than a 6.5 - he strolled it and was great going forward.

[penihibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Agree mainly but thought Stevenson was MOM for us. So he has to get an 8 for me.

Rocky's save with his foot was outstanding. He has been a matchwinner for us at least twice this year.

Mom for me aswell great 2cd half .
Goalie had two brilliant saves or we were goosed !!

[Still Smiling]

Thought Oli Shaw did well when he came on, receives and controls the ball better than Murray.

[ehf]

Marciano won us the points today, Stokes and Slivka disappointing, everyone one else 5 or 6.

[Sammy7nil]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Marciano 8 - Some great saves, especially the 1 v 1 and the one in the 2nd half

Ambrose 6.5 - Some dodgy moments but Ok overall
Hanlon 8 - Thought he was fab - composed and a very good performance
McGregor 7 - First game back in a while,, I was talking my pal saying he didnt't look up to match speed in the first 5 minues but adjusted quickly, good performance.

Boyle 8 - Maybe a bit generous but I thought he was fantastic today, caused real problems
McGeough 7 - Good again
Slivka 6 - Anonymous today I thought, especially in the 1st
Bartley 7 - Broke up play well and a typical Bartley performance
Stevenson 7 - Won all his 50/50s today and a good perfromance again


Stokes 6 - Thought he was OK, nothing special though
Murray 6 - Done all his usual running, did OK i thought

everyone agree with that?

My gripe is your comments for Efe Stokes Slivka don't seem to be reflected in their score

[SChibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

My gripe is your comments for Efe Stokes Slivka don't seem to be reflected in their score

I'd say 6 was a standard score to be honest. Didn't do anything spectacular but nothing particularly bad either