What Can The Fans Do?

[Pretty Boy]

After yesterdays statment there seems to be lot of anger directed at the club and a lot of lashing out. Some of it seems bordering on uncontrolled which I don't think helps anybody.

I've always believed when you want change and want to make a point having a clear head, a clear strategy and a clear aim is important. Turning on fellow supporters and directing anger at all the wrong places helps no one.

So realistically in what way can those who wish to do so make their feelings clear? It seems a lot of people want to make a point but don't really know how to do it. I don't just mean in the short term and specifically Hibs fans either. Can fans from across a range of clubs work together to achieve whatever their aim is? Bearing in mind boycotts rarely gain much support and abusing the board only leads to an unpleasant atmosphere for the team to play in.

Given the Hibs statement is hardly the first indication that nothing further is going to happen I assume the wheels are already in motion re some plans of coordinated action? It would be a shame if an issue that some people feel so strongly about is reduced to scattergun criticisms across social media.

[Ozyhibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

After yesterdays statment there seems to be lot of anger directed at the club and a lot of lashing out. Some of it seems bordering on uncontrolled which I don't think helps anybody.

I've always believed when you want change and want to make a point having a clear head, a clear strategy and a clear aim is important. Turning on fellow supporters and directing anger at all the wrong places helps no one.

So realistically in what way can those who wish to do so make their feelings clear? It seems a lot of people want to make a point but don't really know how to do it. I don't just mean in the short term and specifically Hibs fans either. Can fans from across a range of clubs work together to achieve whatever their aim is? Bearing in mind boycotts rarely gain much support and abusing the board only leads to an unpleasant atmosphere for the team to play in.

Given the Hibs statement is hardly the first indication that nothing further is going to happen I assume the wheels are already in motion re some plans of coordinated action? It would be a shame if an issue that some people feel so strongly about is reduced to scattergun criticisms across social media.

It's a nice idea but Hibs fans don't really have any organisation to take their views forward.
Even a banner at Easter road is likely to be confiscated before it is even unfolded.
As a support we just kind of accept things and muddle on.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[marinello59]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

It's a nice idea but Hibs fans don't really have any organisation to take their views forward. Even a banner at Easter road is likely to be confiscated before it is even unfolded.
As a support we just kind of accept things and muddle on.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That is true of fans of all clubs. Statements will be issued but they will really achieve nothing on their own. If people really want to take this on and crowd fund etc then things will need to be organised on a national basis. Is there an existing organisation that would be best placed to co-ordinate things?

[silverhibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

After yesterdays statment there seems to be lot of anger directed at the club and a lot of lashing out. Some of it seems bordering on uncontrolled which I don't think helps anybody.

I've always believed when you want change and want to make a point having a clear head, a clear strategy and a clear aim is important. Turning on fellow supporters and directing anger at all the wrong places helps no one.

So realistically in what way can those who wish to do so make their feelings clear? It seems a lot of people want to make a point but don't really know how to do it. I don't just mean in the short term and specifically Hibs fans either. Can fans from across a range of clubs work together to achieve whatever their aim is? Bearing in mind boycotts rarely gain much support and abusing the board only leads to an unpleasant atmosphere for the team to play in.

Given the Hibs statement is hardly the first indication that nothing further is going to happen I assume the wheels are already in motion re some plans of coordinated action? It would be a shame if an issue that some people feel so strongly about is reduced to scattergun criticisms across social media.

Hate to say it but that is what will happen, the board will be in for a tough ride on Saturday from the fans, most of it will be directed at Rod Petrie i would think, as for the players, can't see it affecting them, as long as they aren't getting slated with songs the players should be just fine, a banner to let the board know fans feelings, if it got in to the ground I'm pretty sure it will be removed by security under directions from the board.
Can HSA or would they release a statement about the matter.
Or, to gauge the supports feelings how about this, a song, "stand up if you want an enquiry stand up if you want an enquiry etc etc.

[Deansy]

The Aberdeen fans issued a statement that was the opposite view of their chairman - can't we do the same ?

[Basildon Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The Aberdeen fans issued a statement that was the opposite view of their chairman - can't we do the same ?

Aye. Here's their statement:

http://www.donssupporterstogether.co...ebt-statement/

[neil7908]

The trouble is the best way to hit any business is where it hurts - in their pocket.

However, that of course damages the team as it'll affect our budget and ability to retain our best players and bring in new ones come January. So I don't see that as a realistic option.

That's one of the things that's so frustrating about this whole situation and the boards statement. It's left a large number of fans feeling voiceless and out of touch with the game and club they love.

Whatever your views on EBT's I hope everyone would agree that's not a good thing. And it's much harder to 'move on' when fans don't feel listened to our respected.

I'm honestly not sure what we can do. The club won't change their mind that's for sure. I suspect long term the good that's been done since Leanne joined will be partially undone leading to an alienated support.

In the short term the statement is putting pressure on Lennon and the players. The atmosphere won't be great on Saturday and if we don't progress as as well as hoped this season then questions will be asked about the direction and leadership of the club. Again not good for the manager, players or organisation.

I'll be there on Saturday and don't think I'll miss any games because of this but I definitely feel deflated.

[Ozyhibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The trouble is the best way to hit any business is where it hurts - in their pocket.

However, that of course damages the team as it'll affect our budget and ability to retain our best players and bring in new ones come January. So I don't see that as a realistic option.

That's one of the things that's so frustrating about this whole situation and the boards statement. It's left a large number of fans feeling voiceless and out of touch with the game and club they love.

Whatever your views on EBT's I hope everyone would agree that's not a good thing. And it's much harder to 'move on' when fans don't feel listened to our respected.

I'm honestly not sure what we can do. The club won't change their mind that's for sure. I suspect long term the good that's been done since Leanne joined will be partially undone leading to an alienated support.

In the short term the statement is putting pressure on Lennon and the players. The atmosphere won't be great on Saturday and if we don't progress as as well as hoped this season then questions will be asked about the direction and leadership of the club. Again not good for the manager, players or organisation.

I'll be there on Saturday and don't think I'll miss any games because of this but I definitely feel deflated.

Sums up the situation rather well.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Bishop Hibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The trouble is the best way to hit any business is where it hurts - in their pocket.

However, that of course damages the team as it'll affect our budget and ability to retain our best players and bring in new ones come January. So I don't see that as a realistic option.

That's one of the things that's so frustrating about this whole situation and the boards statement. It's left a large number of fans feeling voiceless and out of touch with the game and club they love.

Whatever your views on EBT's I hope everyone would agree that's not a good thing. And it's much harder to 'move on' when fans don't feel listened to our respected.

I'm honestly not sure what we can do. The club won't change their mind that's for sure. I suspect long term the good that's been done since Leanne joined will be partially undone leading to an alienated support.

In the short term the statement is putting pressure on Lennon and the players. The atmosphere won't be great on Saturday and if we don't progress as as well as hoped this season then questions will be asked about the direction and leadership of the club. Again not good for the manager, players or organisation.

I'll be there on Saturday and don't think I'll miss any games because of this but I definitely feel deflated.

Pretty much how I feel. I'd have packed Hibs in if The rangers had been allowed to start life in the top league. So would a substantial number of others. That's the only reason Hibs board took the stance they did to placate the fans. It's quite obvious from this statement that they don't give a damn about fair governance of Scottish football. Depressing really but Petrie, Dempster etc know the fans won't stay away over this.

[Viva_Palmeiras]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

After yesterdays statment there seems to be lot of anger directed at the club and a lot of lashing out. Some of it seems bordering on uncontrolled which I don't think helps anybody.

I've always believed when you want change and want to make a point having a clear head, a clear strategy and a clear aim is important. Turning on fellow supporters and directing anger at all the wrong places helps no one.

So realistically in what way can those who wish to do so make their feelings clear? It seems a lot of people want to make a point but don't really know how to do it. I don't just mean in the short term and specifically Hibs fans either. Can fans from across a range of clubs work together to achieve whatever their aim is? Bearing in mind boycotts rarely gain much support and abusing the board only leads to an unpleasant atmosphere for the team to play in.

Given the Hibs statement is hardly the first indication that nothing further is going to happen I assume the wheels are already in motion re some plans of coordinated action? It would be a shame if an issue that some people feel so strongly about is reduced to scattergun criticisms across social media.

Who were here the guys (Hibees - was it WorcesterHibee?) that setup the first football survey? They passed the baton on and iirc surveys are now controlled by some other entity. Presumably they didn't sign a gagging order maybe they could canvass opinion again?

[worcesterhibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Who were here the guys (Hibees - was it WorcesterHibee?) that setup the first football survey? They passed the baton on and iirc surveys are now controlled by some other entity. Presumably they didn't sign a gagging order maybe they could canvass opinion again?

Can't take credit for that I'm afraid..wasn't me.

[JeMeSouviens]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Can't take credit for that I'm afraid..wasn't me.

It was Cheshire Hibee - seen one obscure English county, seen them all.

[Michael]

Buy as much of the club as possible.

[HappyAsHellas]

It was such a missed opportunity for the club - even if they believed the legal aspect they could have still called for an enquiry into the cheating everyone knows went on. The danger now is that no one will take the lead and get all fans from all clubs involved. I honestly think the fans way is the only way forward but have no idea how they get the ball rolling.

[lapsedhibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

It was such a missed opportunity for the club - even if they believed the legal aspect they could have still called for an enquiry into the cheating everyone knows went on. The danger now is that no one will take the lead and get all fans from all clubs involved. I honestly think the fans way is the only way forward but have no idea how they get the ball rolling.

I think Celtc will continue to press the SFA, just as they did when Jim Farry messed them around. I don't think they'll let it lie just because a variety of other club chairmen toe the SFA line about raking over old coals.

[Hibernia&Alba]

What about something basic, like a petition at games? If the board are presented with the names of ten thousand Hibs fans, they will at least understand the extent of the feeling.

[jacomo]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

What about something basic, like a petition at games? If the board are presented with the names of ten thousand Hibs fans, they will at least understand the extent of the feeling.

Plus I'm sure there will be national petitions, protests at games etc.

Fans joining together on this could not be ignored - lots of ways to raise the issue without hurting Hibs financially.

I think the Scottish government might need to step in because SFA is useless. As is SNPs behaviour legislation of course.

[Joe6-2]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

What about something basic, like a petition at games? If the board are presented with the names of ten thousand Hibs fans, they will at least understand the extent of the feeling.

Is there a way we could encourage every club to do this?

[SirDavidsNapper]

The fans can aim a "cheats" chant in the direction of Sevco when we play them at ER. Wind them up and never let them forget. Petitions, verbal abuse aimed at our board etc isn't they way forward and doesn't reflect the view of fans who agreed with the club statement. Anger should be directed at Sevco not Hibernian.

[lapsedhibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The fans can aim a "cheats" chant in the direction of Sevco when we play them at ER. Wind them up and never let them forget. Petitions, verbal abuse aimed at our board etc isn't they way forward and doesn't reflect the view of fans who agreed with the club statement. Anger should be directed at Sevco not Hibernian.

What have Sevco done wrong? All their titles were honestly acquired, weren't they?

[Ozyhibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

What have Sevco done wrong? All their titles were honestly acquired, weren't they?

And they think it's quite funny that our board sided with them anyway. They won't care a bit. Has anyone ever been upset by anything an opposition team sung at us?
A lot of us will probably just have to get used to the fact that our club isn't what we would wish it to be.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[neil7908]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The fans can aim a "cheats" chant in the direction of Sevco when we play them at ER. Wind them up and never let them forget. Petitions, verbal abuse aimed at our board etc isn't they way forward and doesn't reflect the view of fans who agreed with the club statement. Anger should be directed at Sevco not Hibernian.

Sevco and their fans literally couldn't care less. Ditto the players. We as a club have validated their view point so how can we have a go at them for something our club also supports?

Also, how is chanting at Sevco fans during a game actually supporting our team?

I won't be hurling abuse at the board but it's going to happen. How it somehow reflects on the fans who do agree with the statement I'm not clear. Your free to say nothing, shout down those dishing out the abuse or start a petition or chant in support of the board.

[lyonhibs]

Focus 100% on supporting the team would be the best plan of action, as it always is.

Read a lot of stuff about the statement ruining the feel good factor around the club. When it comes to match day atmosphere, that only happens if the fans in attendance make it so which one would hope won't be the case.

[Stonewall]

The guy behind the Rangers Tax Case blog is currently investigating whether there are grounds for requesting a Judicial Review. If it comes to anything it would be crowd funded and seems to be the best way forward.

[GreenLake]

SPFL fans should collect money for legal and public relations professionals to represent them and make sure that club executives are not able to write the narrative for this shameful episode in our football history.

[Winston Ingram]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

After yesterdays statment there seems to be lot of anger directed at the club and a lot of lashing out. Some of it seems bordering on uncontrolled which I don't think helps anybody.

I've always believed when you want change and want to make a point having a clear head, a clear strategy and a clear aim is important. Turning on fellow supporters and directing anger at all the wrong places helps no one.

So realistically in what way can those who wish to do so make their feelings clear? It seems a lot of people want to make a point but don't really know how to do it. I don't just mean in the short term and specifically Hibs fans either. Can fans from across a range of clubs work together to achieve whatever their aim is? Bearing in mind boycotts rarely gain much support and abusing the board only leads to an unpleasant atmosphere for the team to play in.

Given the Hibs statement is hardly the first indication that nothing further is going to happen I assume the wheels are already in motion re some plans of coordinated action? It would be a shame if an issue that some people feel so strongly about is reduced to scattergun criticisms across social media.

I'd be in favour of this.

[SouthsideHarp_Bhoy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I'd be in favour of this.

Best thing in my view is a mass boycott of huns games at easter road - it will send a clear message to clubs, most importantly it will be very visible on TV and it will damage the tv 'product'- plus it would not hit hibs too hard because they would still get the season ticket money.

Personally thats what i am going to do - although i habe no faith it will change anything, fitb fans are notoriously bad in this country at using their collective power.

Edit - i would also contribute to any crowdfunding, but judicial review would be enormously expensive.

[WhileTheChief..]

Saturdays game won't be affected by this at all.

The wailing and gnashing of teeth is pretty much a social media thing. I've Yet to hear it mentioned once in 'real' life.

I just don't think that you have will support for any plans within the Hibs support generally.

[High-On-Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Saturdays game won't be affected by this at all.

The wailing and gnashing of teeth is pretty much a social media thing. I've Yet to hear it mentioned once in 'real' life.

I just don't think that you have will support for any plans within the Hibs support generally.

That's because so many people won't even be aware of it. Those who i've spoken to who are aware of it, are furious about it. Those who don't take to things like social media and forums are left scratching their heads, because they have no sense of any of it.

[Pretty Boy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

That's because so many people won't even be aware of it. Those who i've spoken to who are aware of it, are furious about it. Those who don't take to things like social media and forums are left scratching their heads, because they have no sense of any of it.

Cheer up, Barcelona won last night.