Rocky ....... 8 ....... Made some brilliant saves and absolutely blameless for that shambles, even Gianluigi Buffon wouldn't have kept a clean sheet with that mess in front of him.
Whittaker .... 5 ..... One decent pass and a very good tackle in the first half, but not terribly effective apart from that.
Ambrose ..... 5 ...... And lucky to get that, poor defensively ... what was in his mind when he tried to beat two Hamilton forwards on the east stand touchline when he had an easy out ball?, by the time he had stopped faffing about we were in all sorts of bother .. he has to cut this crap out.
Hanlon ..... 5 ..... A player I admire, but that was his poorest game for a long time, what the hell was he thinking with the pass that gifted Hamilton the 2nd?
McGregor .... 6 ...... The pick of a bad bunch on the day, but even he had a few poor moments ... I was too far away to see if his penalty challenge was daft or not.
Stevenson .... 6 ..... Gave his all as he always does, his crossing was poor but we had worse on the pitch.
McGeouch ..... 7 .... Probably our best player in the first half, not sure why he was hooked because it could have been anybody else before him.
McGinn ..... 6 .... A shadow of the player he has been since the season started, by the time he did start to show something we were already 1 - 3 down and it was too late.
Swanson ..... 4 ...... I'm struggling to see what it is Danny is supposed to be adding to this team, in every game I've seen him in he has been pretty average to say the least and the 'trying too hard' tag is beginning to wear off for me.
Murray ..... 5 .... Missed a decent chance with a first half header and didn't appear to show the energy he has in previous games ... not all his fault though because he had next to no service.
Stokes .... 5 ...... Sorry but I expect much much more from a player of his experience and ability, he was absolutely anonymous for huge chunks of the game and when he did get a chance his shooting was powder puff weak .... I hope match fitness is his problem because so far what we are getting is not worth the time effort and money we have expended getting him to sign .... took his goal well, which is why its a 5 and not a 4.
SUBS:
Barker ..... 4 ...... Showed in flashes what we might be able to expect from him, but if he thought the Scottish premiership was going to be a cakewalk he will have had his eyes well and truly opened yesterday.
Slivka .... 5 ..... Did his best to make an impression when he came on and after witnessing the 2nd half shambles which proceeded his introduction he's entitled to be asking what he has to do to be a regular starter.
Matulevicius ... 5 .... He made a difference and set up Stokes for his goal ... unlucky not to have been brought on earlier IMO.
Neil Lennon ...... 5 .... Half the teams that come to Easter Road are going to play the way Hamilton did yesterday, it was like watching one of our league games from the last two seasons, apart from the fact that Hamilton clearly have the quality they didn't and boy did it show in the way they executed their game plan. He will know he has to come up with better than this if we are to gain the points, especially at home, we will need to finish in a European place.
I'm not panicking yet though ...... That's the team and performance slated, which is what they deserved, but I know we can play a lot lot better than that .... We have still had a decent start to the season if you swap yesterday for a defeat at Ibrox, but now we have to learn and realise that you get nothing for nothing in this league ..... learn and we will be fine, fail to learn and it will be a long season.
Results 1 to 15 of 15
Thread: Player ratings .. Hamilton game
-
20-08-2017 11:20 AM #1
Player ratings .. Hamilton game
-
-
-
-
20-08-2017 12:36 PM #5This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
20-08-2017 12:39 PM #6
- Join Date
- Apr 2002
- Posts
- 290
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
20-08-2017 12:40 PM #7
Personally though SJM played ok, wasn't helped by the fact that to a man everyone around him were having a howler. DMcG didn't play any better than john.
-
20-08-2017 12:50 PM #8
- Join Date
- Apr 2011
- Posts
- 3,181
I would lower everyones ratings by two and i agree.
-
-
20-08-2017 01:42 PM #10This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Some very generous ratings there IMO.
Rocky - Didn't really do anything wrong in fairness, not at fault for the goals.
Whittaker - Shocker from him
Ambrose - Very shaky
Hanlon - Howler for the 2nd
Stevenson - Tried but a poor day for him
McGreagor - Won everything in the air as usual but otherwise an off day by his standards
McGeough - Not the worst on the park but gave the ball away more times than I can remember
McGinn - Made some good runs through the middle
Stokes - Disapppointing and sadly didn't look too interested. Perhaps we need to tell him every week that we're playing Sevco?
Murray - Very quiet
Swanson - Passenger
Sorry if that sounds harsh but I'm really struggling to find positive points, an all round very poor show.
-
20-08-2017 01:49 PM #11
- Join Date
- May 2002
- Posts
- 10,657
Echo others, those scores are overly generous. Every Hibs player fell well short of their own standards by some distance and some were simply rotten. Would have been with rights to withhold the MOTM announcement, as anyone chosen from he Hibs side would be embarrassed by it.
In saying all that, Lennon needs to score a 1 / 10 for team set-up, substitutions and motivation.
-
20-08-2017 02:07 PM #12
- Join Date
- Jan 2017
- Age
- 66
- Posts
- 62
Agree the changes were a bit strange.... Stokes clearly isn't match fit yet so maybe not a good idea to start him.....Swanson will be better sooner rather than later. Hamilton crowded the ball and we didn't cope with it. We wanted to pick the killer rather than simple pass and ended up doing neither. Any Dundee next week away so they might have to open up a bit and they are pish so let's get back on track then....
Sent from my Lenovo YT3-X50F using Tapatalk
-
20-08-2017 02:09 PM #13This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Seriously though, if I give a player a 5 you can pretty well take it as read I was far from impressed ... I usually start from a 3 for turning up and getting picked.
-
21-08-2017 10:48 AM #14This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
21-08-2017 12:13 PM #15This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Log in to remove the advert |
Bookmarks