Worst Hibs 11 since 2000

[sleeping giant]

I would still consider a reach around with James McPake

[Sir David Gray]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Really? We reportedly went all out to sign him, paid him a really decent wage and when he wasn't on the injury bench he was an absolute bombscare.

But then again he gave the whole "Ooooo I like Hibs and Edinburgh" chat so people fell for it. Cost us the league cup derby vs Hertz by getting himself sent off and cost us goal after goal after goal whilst being paid nicely.

Wage thief.

That's a ridiculous accusation to make.

[skipster7]

This thread is giving me nightmares ! How we never went down with O Hanlon and Stephens at CB defies belief. O Hanlon was a trier but murder but the boy Stephens was right up there with the worst I've seen. Absolutely shocking although I seem to remember a fair few thinking " there was a player in there " ;-)

[silverhibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Tell me what he did for us once he signed his two year contract on a high wage.

Got injured.

[silverhibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Really? We reportedly went all out to sign him, paid him a really decent wage and when he wasn't on the injury bench he was an absolute bombscare.

But then again he gave the whole "Ooooo I like Hibs and Edinburgh" chat so people fell for it. Cost us the league cup derby vs Hertz by getting himself sent off and cost us goal after goal after goal whilst being paid nicely.

Wage thief.

Give you that.

Hate it when folk say that about football players from folk who have never played football before at any decent level.

tut tut

[gillythehibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Really? We reportedly went all out to sign him, paid him a really decent wage and when he wasn't on the injury bench he was an absolute bombscare.

But then again he gave the whole "Ooooo I like Hibs and Edinburgh" chat so people fell for it. Cost us the league cup derby vs Hertz by getting himself sent off and cost us goal after goal after goal whilst being paid nicely.

Wage thief.

You're either angry or clueless. "getting himself sent off" Really ?? Looked a man committed in the tackle for me and showed he cared. Getting sent off doesn't make him bad. Nowhere near that worst 11.

[Northernhibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

You're either angry or clueless. "getting himself sent off" Really ?? Looked a man committed in the tackle for me and showed he cared. Getting sent off doesn't make him bad. Nowhere near that worst 11.

Wild lunge every day of the week.

[My_Wife_Camille]

Quite sad how hard it is to narrow it down to just 11 players..

I've done the opposite if a few people and haven't based mine on footballing ability but more on just how ***** they were in green and white.

Malkowski

Hart
O'Hanlon
Murdock
McGivern - only pips Kujabi to the post because we had to put up with him longer.

Soares
De Graaf
Craig
O'Brien

Collins
Vine

Think I counted 8 league goals between that lot!

[Smartie]

No mention of Jonathan Grounds in here?

We've got some competition for the left-back and striker slots, that's for sure.

[spike220]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Malkowski

Hart
O'Hanlon
Stephens
Zarabi

Soares
Kerr
Keenan
O'Brien

Agogo
O'Donovan

I would have have Doherty as my Captain.

[KDY Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I would have have Doherty as my Captain.

McGivern x 11

[spike220]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

McGivern x 11

Did you see Doherty's post cup final interview or tweets?

[KDY Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Did you see Doherty's post cup final interview or tweets?

Did you see McGivern?

[seven nowt]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Graeme Smith

Michael Hart
Sean O'Hanlon
James McPake
Pa Saikou Kujabi

Edwin De Graaf
Alan O'Brien
Brian Kerr
Matty Done

Shefki Kuqi
Eduardo Hurtado

Subs:
Zibi
David Stephens
Matt Doherty
Richie Towell
Matt Thornhill
Daryll Duffy
Roy O'Donovan

Management: Terry Butcher with Colin Calderwood as assistant

McPake should not get a mention on this page. He was amazing for us. He dipped in form but he would have got back to his best given the chance.

[MWHIBBIES]

Liam Craig isn't even top 100 never mind worst 11.

[Squealing pig]

Don't know about worst but this is near the best

[yogi_campfire]

McNeil

Hart. Mcduroch. Joneliet. Kubaji

Soares. Wiss. De Graaf. O'brien

Kuqi. Trakis

[Stewboy]

The Tank?

[GlesgaeHibby]

Simon Brown
Gathuessi Martis Canning McGivern
O'Brien Soares Noubissie
Nish Kuqi Trakys

[InterviewLoI]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I'd agree with this. It happened so bloody often though, and the derbies mean a lot to us so he leapfrogs a few inferior keepers as a result (Smith for one).

I also don't think Doherty or Kujabi were that bad but they chose to have their worst performance for Hibs at the worst possible moment. Even then, they were hung out to dry by our formation on the day. But they'd both had a few decent performances in the second part of that season and they were an improvement on who we had prior to them arriving.

And if Doherty hadn't acted like such a plum after "that" game he'd be nowhere near these lists.

Doherty wasn't even that bad in "That game", it was just his post-match comments.

[LaMotta]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Simon Brown
Gathuessi Martis Canning McGivern
O'Brien Soares Noubissie
Nish Kuqi Trakys

Gathuessi, Martis, Canning, Nish and Trakys????? Surely you can come up with worse than these guys all of whom had some decent games for Hibs.

Martis scored a couple of own goals but at least one of them was just an unlucky deflection. He was good under Mowbray and once Collins came his form dipped.

Canning didnt do much wrong...currently he is part of a team 2 points off the lead in the premiership.

And just cause Trakys didnt score doesnt make him a bad player, he had a couple of excellent games for us in his short spell.

[LaMotta]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The more I think about his performances in derbies the more I am tending to think that something a little bit shady was going on with him. Almost every derby was a monstrosity for him. We were horsing them 2 0 at ER and he threw 2 in. The semi, then immediately after that the game where Benji scored he gifted them the equaliser then the free kick flap when we were the better team. Way too many IMO.

Zibby had to be on Romanov's payroll, it's the only explanation. I dont remember bonkers mistakes of a similar nature against any other team.

[GlesgaeHibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Gathuessi, Martis, Canning, Nish and Trakys????? Surely you can come up with worse than these guys all of whom had some decent games for Hibs.

Martis scored a couple of own goals but at least one of them was just an unlucky deflection. He was good under Mowbray and once Collins came his form dipped.

Canning didnt do much wrong...currently he is part of a team 2 points off the lead in the premiership.

And just cause Trakys didnt score doesnt make him a bad player, he had a couple of excellent games for us in his short spell.

Gathuessi was a total bombscare, Canning was terrible for us (great for Hamilton). I'd forgot about Francis Dickoh, he'd be in there somewhere.

Trakys was a hopeless journeyman, slower than a week in jail.

Nish is dreadful. One of the most infuriating players to watch.

[21.05.2016]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Are you confusing Ross Campbell and Ross Caldwell?

Aaah apologies yes I have, mis-read the name lol!

[GreenArmyyy!]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I'd agree with this. It happened so bloody often though, and the derbies mean a lot to us so he leapfrogs a few inferior keepers as a result (Smith for one).

I also don't think Doherty or Kujabi were that bad but they chose to have their worst performance for Hibs at the worst possible moment. Even then, they were hung out to dry by our formation on the day. But they'd both had a few decent performances in the second part of that season and they were an improvement on who we had prior to them arriving.

And if Doherty hadn't acted like such a plum after "that" game he'd be nowhere near these lists.

To be fair I never really liked Doherty, always prefered Francombe (think that was his name) but he never got nearly the chance he should have. Regarding Kujabi I find it a shame to be honest. I thought him at left back was always suspect to say the least, Fenlon should have spotted that and adapted. I always thought he would have made a decent LM player. We needed a scapegoat after that final and because of that challenge he was easy pickings.

[GreenArmyyy!]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

McPake should not get a mention on this page. He was amazing for us. He dipped in form but he would have got back to his best given the chance.

McPake should be nowhere near this thread. Don't think Towell should either tbh.

[21.05.2016]

Matt Doherty was an ALRIGHT player, not great by any stretch of the imagination but certainly not the worst. However, what got me with him with just his sheer arrogance and "i'm far too big for this club" attitude. His comments after the 2012 final about "not giving a ****" basically sums up it. Just a billy big baws with a very over inflated ego. Another waste of space that couldn't give a ****, subjected us to one of the most humiliating results in our history, collected his wage packet and ****ed off out the door without a care in the world.

Alan O'Brien - well where do I even begin. When we signed him there was so much hype surrounding him, how he was supposidly faster and better than Sproule etc. What a complete nightmare of a signing! Definitly up there with the worst.

Rowan Vine - awful, couldn't hit a barn door, dreadful dreadful player

Malkowski - need I say more

[erin go bragh]

Only one team managed to get us relegated since 2000 , so surley they are the worst ,

Ggtth