Scott Brown and Larry Kingston both lose appeals

[matty_f]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Did Liam Miller jump 3 feet in the air to rake his studs down the back of a players bawsack?

Is he comparing apples and pears here?

Fat Jim Knew is using typical Yam-logic here, in the event of any type of failing, simply compare it to your benchmark (in this case, Hibs) and make a statement about them instead.

See also Stevie Fail for numerous examples of this type of behaviour.

[CelticEnd]

The whole appeal's and video review panel system in Scotland is completely and utterly flawed. There is no rhyme no reason why some things are referred and some aren't. Scottish football is in a terrible state and the draconian disciplinary system they have in place doesn't help matters.

[johnrebus]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The whole appeal's and video review panel system in Scotland is completely and utterly flawed. There is no rhyme no reason why some things are referred and some aren't. Scottish football is in a terrible state and the draconian disciplinary system they have in place doesn't help matters.

Yes, and why is it in this terrible state?

Basically because you and most of the other sheep like fans in this country blindly follow a glory trail led by two odious institutions hell bent on looking after their own interests to the exclusion of everyone else.

The sooner the Ugly Sisters disappear into the Atlantic League/Premiership/Glasgow Cup, the better.




PS

Broons red card was a stonewaller.

[seanraff07]

Let me guess Hearts fans will forget about the close to 10 penalties they've been awarded this season and claim their's a conspiracy against them again.

[PaulSmith]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The whole appeal's and video review panel system in Scotland is completely and utterly flawed. There is no rhyme no reason why some things are referred and some aren't. Scottish football is in a terrible state and the draconian disciplinary system they have in place doesn't help matters.

It's quite simple, referee looks at the offence that was appealed and if he thinks it was justified after talking it through with the referee's dept then the red card offence will stand.

If he isn't satisfied then he will refer it to a panel.

Simple?

[Nakedmanoncrack]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Brown put the head in to the guy's chest Zidane-style. He couldn't have expected anything else than a red card for that. Why does anyone think otherwise?

Not quite as extreme as the Zidane incident, but that is irrelevant, it was undoubtedly violent conduct and a deserved red card.