Snookered!
The lessons Scottish Football could learn from Scottish Snooker
Our other national sport is in a state of
crisis, rather like football, our official
national sport. For the first time in nearly a decade, not a single
Scot made it to the semi-final of the World Professional Snooker
Championship. Some crisis. I am sure the powers that be in the
Scottish Football Association would be falling over themselves to be
landed with the equivalent crisis in football. It would be along the
lines of no Scottish Football team making the semi-finals of the
Champions League for the first time in ten years, which right now is
a laughable prospect. Indeed if Scotland could achieve the same kind
of domination that it enjoys over Snooker in say Football, Rugby,
Hockey and Gymnastics, Scotland would be a much fitter and healthier
nation than we currently are, with all the benefits to Government
that brings. There are lessons to be learned, and a number of
factors were at play. Snookers success has not come about by
chance.
The first factor was access:
televised snooker created a demand for the sport amongst youngsters.
The Scottish Billiards & Snooker Association sought to exploit this
by encouraging Snooker clubs to let under eighteens access their
premises, often when licensing laws meant that clubs couldnt serve
alcohol e.g. Sunday mornings, but nevertheless access was
guaranteed. In the home, nearly everyone also had a half-size table
meaning that practice was fairly straightforward. Compared with
schools selling playing fields, and traditional sporting areas being
built over, that is almost a revolutionary approach. If children
have nowhere to play the sport themselves (e.g. football), they will
not be able to improve, nor will the experience the enjoyment of
playing. Ultimately children must be encouraged to play sport and to
engage in physical activity.
That must be recognised by
Government as well as by football clubs, particularly as we appear
to be in the process of storing up a health-related time bomb for
the Scottish taxpayer. In addition, construction of indoor and
all-weather pitches is something that needs to happen as Scotlands
climate mitigates against such activity, something anyone who has
ever tried to play 5-a-side football at the Pitz in Sighthill on a
freezing cold, wet and windy Tuesday night will testify.
The second factor in Snookers
success was coaching: a network of coaches was rapidly established
in major snooker clubs, with professional players like Jim Donnelly
giving up time on Saturday and Sunday mornings to coach aspiring
players, helping to sustain an interest in the game. This seems to
be something that football and rugby are only just beginning to
latch on to via coaching schemes. Perhaps government could give
clubs tax breaks to run such schemes. After all, as stated earlier,
both benefit.
Also critical was competition: a
Scottish circuit of tournaments was arranged for junior players,
each consisting of a knockout competition held over two Saturdays.
Ranking points were awarded for placing in the quarter final stages
and beyond, with an official ranking drawn up based on that.
Coaching and practice were given to the most talented players based
on their performances in such tournaments, with the Association
assisting them in playing across the country and in events in
England and abroad. I am no expert on youth football development in
Scotland, but its worth looking to see if football can learn here.
In short, Snooker pursued a
systematic policy of development across Scotland with a view to
unearthing as much new talent as possible. The real skill was that
it was a system aimed at encouraging youngsters to play the game:
for every professional earning a living from the game there are
hundreds of people playing in a club or in a Sunday league
tournament, and domination of a professional sport cannot happen
without it. The success of the policy can be measured by the fact
that amongst my contemporaries were the likes of John Higgins, Alan
McManus and Stephen Hendry, the latter being arguably the greatest
player in the history of the game. I played against the first two in
their formative years. They absolutely horsed me, but the point was
that I and many others enjoyed the game, even if we didnt make it.
Football, Rugby and Government could learn a lot from Snooker, a
major Scottish success story.